Albrecht Hendrik Christian, Wagner Sophie, Sandbrink Christoph, Gretschel Stephan
Department of General, Visceral, Thoracic and Vascular Surgery, University Hospital Ruppin- Brandenburg, Neuruppin, Germany.
Faculty of Health Sciences Brandenburg, Brandenburg Medical School Theodor Fontane, Neuruppin, Germany.
Front Surg. 2023 Feb 17;10:1106177. doi: 10.3389/fsurg.2023.1106177. eCollection 2023.
Neoadjuvant conventional chemoradiation (CRT) is the standard treatment for primary locally non-curatively resectable rectal cancer, as tumor downsizing may allow R0 resectability. Short-term neoadjuvant radiotherapy (5x5 Gy) followed by an interval before surgery (SRT- delay) is an alternative for multimorbid patients who cannot tolerate CRT. This study examined the extent of tumor downsizing achieved with the SRT-delay approach in a limited cohort that underwent complete re-staging before surgery.
Between March 2018 and July 2021, 26 patients with locally advanced primary adenocarcinoma (>uT3 or/and N+) of the rectum were treated with SRT-delay. 22 patients underwent initial staging and complete re-staging (CT, endoscopy, MRI). Tumor downsizing was assessed by staging and re-staging data and pathologic findings. Semiautomated measurement of tumor volume was performed using mint Lesion™ 1.8 software to evaluate tumor regression.
The mean tumor diameter determined on sagittal T2 MRI images decreased significantly from 54.1 (23-78) mm at initial staging to 37.9 (18-65) mm at re-staging before surgery (p <0.001) and to 25.5 (7-58) mm at pathologic examination (p <0.001). This corresponds to a mean reduction in tumor diameter of 28.9 (4.3-60.7) % at re-staging and 51.1 (8.7-86.5) % at pathology. Mean tumor volume determined from transverse T2 MR images mint Lesion 1.8 software significantly decreased from 27.5 (9.8 - 89.6) cm at initial staging to 13.1 (3.7 - 32.8) cm at re-staging (p <0.001), corresponding to a mean reduction of 50.8 (21.6 - 77) %. The frequency of positive circumferential resection margin (CRM) (less than 1mm) decreased from 45,5 % (10 patients) at initial staging to 18,2 % (4 patients) at re-staging. On pathologic examination, the CRM was negative in all cases. However, multivisceral resection for T4 tumors was required in 2 patients (9%). Tumor downstaging was noted in 15 of 22 patients after SRT-delay.
In conclusion, the observed extent of downsizing is broadly comparable to the results of CRT, making SRT-delay a serious alternative for patients who cannot tolerate chemotherapy.
新辅助常规放化疗(CRT)是原发性局部无法根治性切除直肠癌的标准治疗方法,因为肿瘤缩小可能使肿瘤能够进行R0切除。短期新辅助放疗(5×5 Gy),然后在手术前间隔一段时间(SRT延迟)是无法耐受CRT的多合并症患者的一种替代方案。本研究在一组术前进行了全面重新分期的有限队列中,研究了SRT延迟方法实现的肿瘤缩小程度。
2018年3月至2021年7月期间,26例直肠局部晚期原发性腺癌(>uT3或/和N+)患者接受了SRT延迟治疗。22例患者进行了初始分期和全面重新分期(CT、内镜检查、MRI)。通过分期和重新分期数据以及病理结果评估肿瘤缩小情况。使用mint Lesion™ 1.8软件对肿瘤体积进行半自动测量,以评估肿瘤退缩情况。
矢状面T2 MRI图像上确定的平均肿瘤直径从初始分期时的54.1(23 - 78)mm显著降至手术前重新分期时的37.9(18 - 65)mm(p <0.001),病理检查时降至25.5(7 - 58)mm(p <0.001)。这相当于重新分期时肿瘤直径平均缩小28.9(4.3 - 60.7)%,病理检查时缩小51.1(8.7 - 86.5)%。根据横断面T2 MR图像和mint Lesion 1.8软件确定的平均肿瘤体积从初始分期时的27.5(9.8 - 89.6)cm显著降至重新分期时的13.1(3.7 - 32.8)cm(p <0.001),平均缩小50.8(21.6 - 77)%。环周切缘(CRM)阳性(小于1mm)的频率从初始分期时的45.5%(10例患者)降至重新分期时的18.2%(4例患者)。病理检查时,所有病例的CRM均为阴性。然而,2例(9%)患者因T4肿瘤需要进行多脏器切除。22例患者中有15例在SRT延迟后出现肿瘤降期。
总之,观察到的缩小程度与CRT的结果大致相当,这使得SRT延迟成为无法耐受化疗患者的一种重要替代方案。