中国城市空气净化器去除室内颗粒物干预措施:成本效益与健康不平等影响研究
Air Purifier Intervention to Remove Indoor PM in Urban China: A Cost-Effectiveness and Health Inequality Impact Study.
作者信息
Zhang Ao, Liu Yumeng, Ji John S, Zhao Bin
机构信息
Department of Building Science, School of Architecture, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China.
Vanke School of Public Health, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China.
出版信息
Environ Sci Technol. 2023 Mar 21;57(11):4492-4503. doi: 10.1021/acs.est.2c09730. Epub 2023 Mar 7.
Using air purifiers is an intervention to reduce exposure to fine particulate matter (PM) for health benefits. We performed a comprehensive simulation in urban China to estimate the cost-effectiveness of long-term use of air purifiers to remove indoor PM from indoor and ambient air pollution in five intervention scenarios (S1-S5), where the indoor PM targets were 35, 25, 15, 10, and 5 μg/m, respectively. In scenarios S1 to S5, 5221 (95% uncertainty interval: 3886-6091), 6178 (4554-7242), 8599 (6255-10,109), 11,006 (7962-13,013), and 14,990 (10,888-17,610) thousand disability-adjusted-life-years (DALYs) can be avoided at the cost of 201 (199-204), 240 (238-243), 364 (360-369), 522 (515-530), and 921 (905-939) billion Chinese Yuan (CNY), respectively. A high disparity in per capita health benefits and costs was observed by city, which expanded with the decrease of the indoor PM target. The net benefits of using purifiers in cities varied across scenarios. Cities with a lower ratio of annual average outdoor PM concentration to gross domestic product (GDP) per capita tended to achieve higher net benefits in the scenario with a lower indoor PM target. Controlling ambient PM pollution and developing the economy can reduce the inequality in air purifier use across China.
使用空气净化器是一种减少接触细颗粒物(PM)以促进健康的干预措施。我们在中国城市进行了一项全面模拟,以估计在五种干预情景(S1 - S5)下长期使用空气净化器从室内和环境空气污染中去除室内PM的成本效益,其中室内PM目标分别为35、25、15、10和5 μg/m³。在情景S1至S5中,分别以201(199 - 204)、240(238 - 243)、364(360 - 369)、522(515 - 530)和921(905 - 939)亿元人民币的成本可避免5221(95%不确定区间:3886 - 6091)、6178(4554 - 7242)、8599(6255 - 10109)、11006(7962 - 13013)和14990(10888 - 17610)千伤残调整生命年(DALYs)。按城市观察到人均健康效益和成本存在很大差异,且随着室内PM目标的降低而扩大。在不同情景下,城市使用净化器的净效益各不相同。年平均室外PM浓度与人均国内生产总值(GDP)比率较低的城市,在室内PM目标较低的情景中往往能实现更高的净效益。控制环境PM污染和发展经济可以减少中国空气净化器使用的不平等现象。