Van Ness M M, Chobanian S J, Winters C, Diehl A M, Esposito R L, Cattau E L
Department of Medicine, Naval Hospital, Bethesda, Md 20814-5011.
Arch Intern Med. 1987 Dec;147(12):2175-6. doi: 10.1001/archinte.147.12.2175.
To our knowledge, no previous study has addressed the question of which method of evaluation of the lower gastrointestinal tract is preferred by patients, air-contrast barium enema or colonoscopy. Over a four-month period, we asked 189 consecutive patients who had undergone colonoscopy to express their preference for either air-contrast barium enema or colonoscopy. A clear preference for colonoscopy was expressed by our patients in terms of comfort and polyp detection despite higher cost. Time lost from work and post-procedure constipation were significantly less for colonoscopy than for barium enema. These factors should be considered in the evaluation of suspected lower gastrointestinal tract disease.
据我们所知,此前尚无研究探讨过患者更倾向于哪种下消化道评估方法,即气钡双重造影灌肠或结肠镜检查。在四个月的时间里,我们询问了189名连续接受结肠镜检查的患者,让他们表达对气钡双重造影灌肠或结肠镜检查的偏好。尽管结肠镜检查费用较高,但我们的患者在舒适度和息肉检测方面明确表示更倾向于结肠镜检查。结肠镜检查导致的工作时间损失和术后便秘明显少于钡灌肠。在评估疑似下消化道疾病时应考虑这些因素。