Lavi-Rotbain Ori, Arnon Inbal
The Edmond and Lilly Safra Center for Brain Sciences, Hebrew University, Jerusalem, Israel.
Department of Psychology, Hebrew University, Jerusalem, Israel.
Open Mind (Camb). 2023 Jan 24;7:1-30. doi: 10.1162/opmi_a_00070. eCollection 2023.
Across languages, word frequency and rank follow a power law relation, forming a distribution known as the Zipfian distribution. There is growing experimental evidence that this well-studied phenomenon may be beneficial for language learning. However, most investigations of word distributions in natural language have focused on adult-to-adult speech: Zipf's law has not been thoroughly evaluated in child-directed speech (CDS) across languages. If Zipfian distributions facilitate learning, they should also be found in CDS. At the same time, several unique properties of CDS may result in a less skewed distribution. Here, we examine the frequency distribution of words in CDS in three studies. We first show that CDS is Zipfian across 15 languages from seven language families. We then show that CDS is Zipfian from early on (six-months) and across development for five languages with sufficient longitudinal data. Finally, we show that the distribution holds across different parts of speech: Nouns, verbs, adjectives and prepositions follow a Zipfian distribution. Together, the results show that the input children hear is skewed in a particular way from early on, providing necessary (but not sufficient) support for the postulated learning advantage of such skew. They highlight the need to study skewed learning environments experimentally.
在各种语言中,词频和词序遵循幂律关系,形成一种称为齐普夫分布的分布。越来越多的实验证据表明,这种经过充分研究的现象可能对语言学习有益。然而,大多数对自然语言中词分布的研究都集中在成人对成人的言语上:齐普夫定律在跨语言的儿童导向言语(CDS)中尚未得到充分评估。如果齐普夫分布有助于学习,那么在儿童导向言语中也应该能发现它们。同时,儿童导向言语的几个独特属性可能会导致分布的偏斜度较小。在这里,我们通过三项研究考察了儿童导向言语中词的频率分布。我们首先表明,来自七个语系的15种语言的儿童导向言语是齐普夫分布的。然后我们表明,对于有足够纵向数据的五种语言,儿童导向言语从早期(六个月)开始并在整个发展过程中都是齐普夫分布的。最后,我们表明这种分布在不同词性中都成立:名词、动词、形容词和介词都遵循齐普夫分布。总之,结果表明儿童听到的输入从早期就以一种特定的方式存在偏斜,为这种偏斜所假定的学习优势提供了必要(但不充分)的支持。它们突出了通过实验研究偏斜学习环境的必要性。