Jiang Qi, Liu Hai-Can, Liu Qing-Yun, Phelan Jody E, Tao Feng-Xi, Zhao Xiu-Qin, Wang Jian, Glynn Judith R, Takiff Howard E, Clark Taane G, Wan Kang-Lin, Gao Qian
Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, School of Public Health, Wuhan University, Wuhan, China.
State Key Laboratory for Infectious Disease Prevention and Control and National Institute for Communicable Disease Control and Prevention, Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Beijing, China.
Microbiol Spectr. 2023 Mar 13;11(2):e0399122. doi: 10.1128/spectrum.03991-22.
On the Tibetan Plateau, most tuberculosis is caused by indigenous Mycobacterium tuberculosis strains with a monophyletic structure and high-level drug resistance. This study investigated the emergence, evolution, and transmission dynamics of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) in Tibet. The whole-genome sequences of 576 clinical strains from Tibet were analyzed with the TB-profiler tool to identify drug-resistance mutations. The evolution of the drug resistance was then inferred based on maximum-likelihood phylogeny and dated trees that traced the serial acquisition of mutations conferring resistance to different drugs. Among the 576 clinical M. tuberculosis strains, 346 (60.1%) carried at least 1 resistance-conferring mutation and 231 (40.1%) were MDR-TB. Using a pairwise distance of 50 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), most strains (89.9%, 518/576) were phylogenetically separated into 50 long-term transmission clusters. Eleven large drug-resistant clusters contained 76.1% (176/231) of the local multidrug-resistant strains. A total of 85.2% of the isoniazid-resistant strains were highly transmitted with an average of 6.6 cases per cluster, of which most shared the mutation KatG Ser315Thr. A lower proportion (71.6%) of multidrug-resistant strains were transmitted, with an average cluster size of 2.9 cases. The isoniazid-resistant clusters appear to have undergone substantial bacterial population growth in the 1970s to 1990s and then subsequently accumulated multiple rifampicin-resistance mutations and caused the current local MDR-TB burden. These findings highlight the importance of detecting and curing isoniazid-resistant strains to prevent the emergence of endemic MDR-TB. Emerging isoniazid resistance in the 1970s allowed M. tuberculosis strains to spread and form into large multidrug-resistant tuberculosis clusters in the isolated plateau of Tibet, China. The epidemic was driven by the high risk of transmission as well as the potential of acquiring further drug resistance from isoniazid-resistant strains. Eleven large drug-resistant clusters consisted of the majority of local multidrug-resistant cases. Among the clusters, isoniazid resistance overwhelmingly evolved before all the other resistance types. A large bacterial population growth of isoniazid-resistant clusters occurred between 1970s and 1990s, which subsequently accumulated rifampicin-resistance-conferring mutations in parallel and accounted for the local multidrug-resistant tuberculosis burden. The results of our study indicate that it may be possible to restrict MDR-TB evolution and dissemination by prioritizing screening for isoniazid (INH)-resistant TB strains before they become MDR-TB and by adopting measures that can limit their transmission.
在青藏高原,大多数结核病是由具有单系结构和高水平耐药性的本地结核分枝杆菌菌株引起的。本研究调查了西藏耐多药结核病(MDR-TB)的出现、演变和传播动态。使用TB-profiler工具分析了来自西藏的576株临床菌株的全基因组序列,以鉴定耐药突变。然后根据最大似然系统发育和追溯赋予不同药物耐药性的突变序列获取情况的定年树推断耐药性的演变。在576株临床结核分枝杆菌菌株中,346株(60.1%)携带至少1个耐药性赋予突变,231株(40.1%)为耐多药结核病。使用50个单核苷酸多态性(SNP)的成对距离,大多数菌株(89.9%,518/576)在系统发育上被分为50个长期传播簇。11个大型耐药簇包含76.1%(176/231)的本地耐多药菌株。总共85.2%的异烟肼耐药菌株传播性高,每个簇平均有6.6例,其中大多数共享KatG Ser315Thr突变。耐多药菌株的传播比例较低(71.6%),平均簇大小为2.9例。异烟肼耐药簇似乎在20世纪70年代至90年代经历了大量细菌种群增长,随后积累了多个利福平耐药突变,导致了当前当地的耐多药结核病负担。这些发现突出了检测和治愈异烟肼耐药菌株以预防地方性耐多药结核病出现的重要性。20世纪70年代出现的异烟肼耐药性使结核分枝杆菌菌株得以传播,并在中国西藏与世隔绝的高原地区形成大型耐多药结核菌群。这种流行是由高传播风险以及从异烟肼耐药菌株获得进一步耐药性的可能性驱动的。11个大型耐药簇构成了大多数本地耐多药病例。在这些簇中,异烟肼耐药性在所有其他耐药类型之前绝大多数已经演变。20世纪70年代至90年代间异烟肼耐药簇出现了大量细菌种群增长,随后并行积累了赋予利福平耐药性的突变,并导致了当地耐多药结核病负担。我们的研究结果表明,通过在耐多药结核病出现之前优先筛查异烟肼(INH)耐药结核菌株,并采取能够限制其传播的措施,有可能限制耐多药结核病的演变和传播。