University of Wuppertal, Gaußstr. 20, 42119 Wuppertal, Germany.
University of Leuven, Oude Markt 13, 3000 Leuven, Belgium.
J Sch Psychol. 2023 Apr;97:101-122. doi: 10.1016/j.jsp.2023.01.005. Epub 2023 Feb 11.
Diversity approaches in school may affect students' interethnic relations but are often only assessed through students' perceptions. We related teacher-reported diversity approaches (i.e., assimilationism, multiculturalism, color-evasion, and intervening with discrimination) to ethnic majority and minority students' ethnic attitudes as well as to their experiences or perceptions of ethnic discrimination. We also explored students' perceptions of teacher approaches as hypothetical mediators of teacher effects on interethnic relations. We coupled survey data from 547 teachers (M = 39.02 years, 70% female) in 64 schools in Belgium with large-scale longitudinal survey data from their students, including 1287 Belgian majority students (M = 15.52, 51% female) and 696 Turkish- or Moroccan-origin minority students (M = 15.92, 58% female) enrolled in the same schools (Phalet et al., 2018). Longitudinal multilevel models revealed that over time, teacher-reported assimilationism predicted (even) more positive attitudes towards Belgian majority members, and multiculturalism predicted less highly positive attitudes towards Belgian majority members among Belgian majority students. Teacher-reported intervening with discrimination predicted more perceived discrimination of ethnic minority students over time among Belgian majority students. We did not find significant longitudinal effects of teachers' diversity approaches with Turkish- or Moroccan-origin minority students' ethnic attitudes, nor with their discrimination experiences or perceptions. We conclude that teachers' multiculturalism and anti-discrimination approaches reduced interethnic bias and raised awareness of discrimination among ethnic majority students. However, different perceptions by teachers and students suggest the need for schools to better communicate inclusive diversity approaches.
学校的多元化方法可能会影响学生的跨种族关系,但通常仅通过学生的感知来评估。我们将教师报告的多元化方法(即同化主义、多元文化主义、回避种族和干预歧视)与多数族裔和少数族裔学生的种族态度以及他们对种族歧视的经历或感知联系起来。我们还探讨了学生对教师方法的看法,将其作为教师对跨种族关系影响的假设中介。我们将来自比利时 64 所学校的 547 名教师(M=39.02 岁,70%为女性)的调查数据与来自同一学校的 1287 名比利时多数族裔学生(M=15.52,51%为女性)和 696 名土耳其裔或摩洛哥裔少数族裔学生(M=15.92,58%为女性)的大规模纵向调查数据结合起来(Phalet 等人,2018)。纵向多层模型显示,随着时间的推移,教师报告的同化主义预测了(甚至)对比利时多数族裔成员更积极的态度,而多元文化主义预测了比利时多数族裔学生对比利时多数族裔成员的态度不那么积极。教师报告的干预歧视预测了比利时多数族裔学生随着时间的推移对少数民族学生的感知歧视会更多。我们没有发现教师的多元化方法对土耳其裔或摩洛哥裔少数族裔学生的种族态度、歧视经历或感知有显著的纵向影响。我们的结论是,教师的多元文化主义和反歧视方法减少了跨种族偏见,提高了多数族裔学生对歧视的认识。然而,教师和学生的不同看法表明,学校需要更好地传达包容的多元化方法。