Cellini Francesco, Narducci Maria Lucia, Pavone Chiara, Bencardino Gianluigi, Perna Francesco, Pinnacchio Gaetano, Chiesa Silvia, Massaccesi Mariangela, Gambacorta Maria Antonietta, Manfrida Stefania, Longo Silvia, Mannocci Alice, Di Gregorio Giuseppe, Boldrini Luca, Tagliaferri Luca, Indovina Luca, Placidi Lorenzo, Stimato Gerardina, Spera Francesco Raffaele, Scacciavillani Roberto, Crea Filippo, Valentini Vincenzo, Pelargonio Gemma
Dipartimento Universitario Diagnostica per Immagini, Radioterapia Oncologica ed Ematologia, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Rome, Italy.
Dipartimento di Diagnostica per Immagini, Radioterapia Oncologica ed Ematologia, Fondazione Policlinico Universitario Agostino Gemelli IRCCS, Rome, Italy.
Front Cardiovasc Med. 2023 Feb 27;10:1020966. doi: 10.3389/fcvm.2023.1020966. eCollection 2023.
Monomorphic ventricular tachycardia (VT) is a life-threatening condition often observed in patients with structural heart disease. Ventricular tachycardia ablation through radiation therapy (VT-ART) for sustained monomorphic ventricular tachycardia seems promising, effective, and safe. VT-ART delivers focused, high-dose radiation, usually in a single fraction of 25 Gy, allowing ablation of VT by inducing myocardial scars. The procedure is fully non-invasive; therefore, it can be easily performed in patients with contraindications to invasive ablation procedures. Definitive data are lacking, and no direct comparison with standard procedures is available.
The aim of this multicenter observational study is to evaluate the efficacy and safety of VT-ART, comparing the clinical outcome of patients undergone to VT-ART to patients not having received such a procedure. The two groups will not be collected by direct, prospective accrual to avoid randomization among the innovative and traditional arm: A retrospective selection through matched pair analysis will collect patients presenting features similar to the ones undergone VT-ART within the consortium (in each center independently). Our trial will enroll patients with optimized medical therapy in whom endocardial and/or epicardial radiofrequency ablation (RFA), the gold standard for VT ablation, is either unfeasible or fails to control VT recurrence. Our primary outcome is investigating the difference in overall cardiovascular survival among the group undergoing VT-ART and the one not exposed to the innovative procedure. The secondary outcome is evaluating the difference in ventricular event-free survival after the last procedure (i.e., last RFA vs. VT-ART) between the two groups. An additional secondary aim is to evaluate the reduction in the number of VT episodes comparing the 3 months before the procedure to the ones recorded at 6 months (from the 4th to 6th month) following VT-ART and RFA, respectively. Other secondary objectives include identifying the benefits of VT-ART on cardiac function, as evaluated through an electrocardiogram, echocardiographic, biochemical variables, and on patient quality of life. We calculated the sample size (in a 2:1 ratio) upon enrolling 149 patients: 100 in the non-exposed control group and 49 in the VT-ART group. Progressively, on a multicentric basis supervised by the promoting center in the VT-ART consortium, for each VT-ART patient enrollment, a matched pair patient profile according to the predefined features will be shared with the consortium to enroll a patient that has not undergone VT-ART.
Our trial will provide insight into the efficacy and safety of VT-ART through a matched pair analysis, an observational, multicentric study of two groups of patients with or without VT-ART in the multicentric consortium (with subgroup stratification into dynamic cohorts).
单形性室性心动过速(VT)是一种常见于结构性心脏病患者的危及生命的疾病。通过放射治疗进行室性心动过速消融(VT-ART)治疗持续性单形性室性心动过速似乎具有前景、有效且安全。VT-ART可提供聚焦的高剂量辐射,通常单次剂量为25 Gy,通过诱导心肌瘢痕来消融室性心动过速。该手术完全无创;因此,对于有创消融手术禁忌的患者也可轻松实施。目前缺乏确凿数据,且无法与标准手术进行直接比较。
这项多中心观察性研究的目的是评估VT-ART的疗效和安全性,将接受VT-ART治疗的患者与未接受该治疗的患者的临床结果进行比较。两组患者不会通过直接的前瞻性入组来收集,以避免在创新组和传统组之间进行随机分组:将通过配对分析进行回顾性选择,在联盟内(每个中心独立进行)收集具有与接受VT-ART治疗患者相似特征的患者。我们的试验将纳入接受优化药物治疗但心内膜和/或心外膜射频消融(RFA,室性心动过速消融的金标准)不可行或无法控制室性心动过速复发的患者。我们的主要结局是研究接受VT-ART治疗的组与未接受该创新手术的组在总体心血管生存率上的差异。次要结局是评估两组在最后一次手术(即最后一次RFA与VT-ART)后无室性事件生存率的差异。另一个次要目标是比较手术前3个月与VT-ART和RFA后6个月(第4至6个月)记录的室性心动过速发作次数的减少情况。其他次要目标包括通过心电图、超声心动图、生化变量评估VT-ART对心脏功能的益处以及对患者生活质量的影响。我们在纳入149例患者时计算了样本量(比例为2:1):未暴露的对照组100例,VT-ART组49例。在VT-ART联盟的牵头中心的多中心监督下,对于每一例VT-ART患者的入组,将根据预先定义的特征与联盟共享配对患者资料,以纳入未接受VT-ART治疗的患者。
我们的试验将通过配对分析对VT-ART的疗效和安全性进行深入研究,这是一项在多中心联盟中对两组有或无VT-ART治疗的患者进行的观察性多中心研究(并将亚组分层为动态队列)。