Pronk Mathilde C, Zuidema Willij C, Weimar Willem, Van De Wetering Jacqueline, Ismail Sohal Y, Massey Emma K
Department of Internal Medicine, Erasmus MC Transplant Institute, University Medical Center Rotterdam, Rotterdam, Netherlands.
Transpl Int. 2023 Feb 28;36:10959. doi: 10.3389/ti.2023.10959. eCollection 2023.
The Netherlands was the first European country to implement unspecified kidney donation in 2000. This qualitative study aimed to evaluate the experiences of unspecified kidney donors (UKDs) in our transplant institute to improve the care for this valuable group of donors. We conducted semi-structured interviews with 106 UKDs who donated between 2000-2016 (response rate 84%). Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed verbatim and independently coded by 2 researchers in NVivo using thematic analysis. The following 14 themes reflecting donor experiences were found: Satisfaction with donation; Support from social network; Interpersonal stress; Complaints about hospital care; Uncertainty about donor approval; Life on hold between approval and actual donation; Donation requires perseverance and commitment; Recovery took longer than expected; Normalization of the donation; Becoming an advocate for living kidney donation; Satisfaction with anonymity; Ongoing curiosity about outcome or recipient; Importance of anonymous communication; Anonymity is not watertight. The data reinforced that unspecified kidney donation is a positive experience for donors and that they were generally satisfied with the procedures. Most important complaints about the procedure concerned the length of the assessment procedure and the lack of acknowledgment for UKDs from both their recipients and health professionals. Suggestions are made to address the needs of UKDs.
荷兰是2000年首个实施非指定肾脏捐赠的欧洲国家。这项定性研究旨在评估我们移植机构中非指定肾脏捐赠者(UKD)的经历,以改善对这一重要捐赠者群体的护理。我们对2000年至2016年间捐赠的106名UKD进行了半结构化访谈(回复率84%)。访谈进行了录音,逐字转录,并由两名研究人员在NVivo中使用主题分析独立编码。发现了以下14个反映捐赠者经历的主题:对捐赠的满意度;来自社交网络的支持;人际压力;对医院护理的投诉;捐赠者批准的不确定性;批准与实际捐赠之间生活暂停;捐赠需要毅力和奉献精神;恢复时间比预期长;捐赠的常态化;成为活体肾脏捐赠的倡导者;对匿名的满意度;对结果或受赠者的持续好奇;匿名沟通的重要性;匿名并非无懈可击。数据强化了非指定肾脏捐赠对捐赠者来说是一次积极的经历,并且他们总体上对程序感到满意。对该程序最重要的投诉涉及评估程序的长度以及受赠者和医疗专业人员对UKD缺乏认可。针对UKD的需求提出了建议。