Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Ankara City Hospital, University of Health Sciences Faculty of Medicine, Ankara, Turkey.
Institutional Data Management Coordination Office, Middle East Technical University, Ankara, Turkey.
Lymphat Res Biol. 2023 Aug;21(4):403-409. doi: 10.1089/lrb.2022.0028. Epub 2023 Mar 16.
YouTube provides information on several health-conditions including lipedema. The aim of this study was to investigate the properties, quality, and quantity of YouTube videos on lipedema. We explored YouTube using the key word lipedema and the initial top 50 videos were included to review. The properties comprising informers, target, and domains of videos covering number of views, likes, dislikes, duration, viewing rate (VR), and video power index (VPI) were recorded. A modified DISCERN tool and global quality scale (GQS) were used to assess the reliability and quality of videos, respectively. The top 50 videos had a mean of 35,805 views, 282 likes, 12 dislikes, and 30 comments. The mean VPI (96.4) and VR (63.8%) were high. The videos were generally uploaded by health professionals for patient/public and health professional targets with the same ratio (50%). The majority of video contents was related to general information (68%) followed by surgical treatment (62%). Only a small ratio of their content (22%) was about nonsurgical management. The reliability and quality of the videos were intermediate to low. The median DISCERN and GQS scores were higher in the videos uploaded by health professional group compared with nonhealth professionals, but the number of views, VPI, and VR were similar between the groups with regard to the source. YouTube videos on lipedema are mostly provided by health professionals targeting both public/patients and health care providers but the content is limited and the quality and reliability of them were low to intermediate. Therefore, the lipedema specialists are suggested to work together to create up-to-date, high-quality, accessible online educational content to meet the needs of both patients/public and the health professionals. In addition, control mechanisms and careful peer reviewing of the videos informed by nonhealth professionals are warranted to avoid misleading information.
YouTube 提供了一些健康状况的信息,包括脂性水肿。本研究旨在调查脂性水肿的 YouTube 视频的性质、质量和数量。我们使用关键字“脂性水肿”在 YouTube 上进行了搜索,纳入了前 50 个视频进行回顾。记录了视频的属性,包括告知者、目标人群和领域,涵盖观看次数、点赞数、不喜欢数、时长、观看率(VR)和视频功率指数(VPI)。使用改良的 DISCERN 工具和全球质量量表(GQS)分别评估视频的可靠性和质量。前 50 个视频的平均观看次数为 35805 次,点赞数为 282 次,不喜欢数为 12 次,评论数为 30 条。平均 VPI(96.4)和 VR(63.8%)都很高。这些视频通常由健康专业人员上传,针对患者/公众和健康专业人员,比例相同(50%)。视频内容主要是一般信息(68%),其次是手术治疗(62%)。只有小部分(22%)内容涉及非手术治疗。视频的可靠性和质量为中低水平。与非健康专业人员相比,由健康专业人员上传的视频的 DISCERN 和 GQS 中位数得分较高,但就来源而言,两组的观看次数、VPI 和 VR 相似。脂性水肿的 YouTube 视频主要由健康专业人员提供,目标人群为患者/公众和医疗保健提供者,但内容有限,且质量和可靠性为中低水平。因此,建议脂性水肿专家共同努力,制作最新的、高质量的、可访问的在线教育内容,以满足患者/公众和健康专业人员的需求。此外,需要控制机制并由非健康专业人员对视频进行仔细的同行评审,以避免误导性信息。