Community and Health Research Unit, University of Lincoln, Lincoln, United Kingdom.
Patient and Public Contributor, Lincoln, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2023 Mar 16;18(3):e0282987. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0282987. eCollection 2023.
"'Hypos' can strike twice" (HS2) is a pragmatic, leaflet-based referral intervention designed for administration by clinicians of the emergency medical services (EMS) to people they have attended and successfully treated for hypoglycaemia. Its main purpose is to encourage the recipient to engage with their general practitioner or diabetic nurse in order that improvements in medical management of their diabetes may be made, thereby reducing their risk of recurrent hypoglycaemia. Herein we build a de novo economic model for purposes of incremental analyses to compare, in 2018-19 prices, HS2 against standard care for recurrent hypoglycaemia in the fortnight following the initial attack from the perspective of the UK National Health Service (NHS). We found that per patient NHS costs incurred by people receiving the HS2 intervention over the fortnight following an initial hypoglycaemia average £49.79, and under standard care costs average £40.50. Target patient benefit assessed over that same period finds the probability of no recurrence of hypoglycaemia averaging 42.4% under HS2 and 39.4% under standard care, a 7.6% reduction in relative risk. We find that implementing HS2 will cost the NHS an additional £309.36 per episode of recurrent hypoglycaemia avoided. Contrary to the favourable support offered in Botan et al., we conclude that in its current form the HS2 intervention is not a cost-effective use of NHS resources when compared to standard NHS care in reducing the risk of hypoglycaemia recurring within a fortnight of an initial attack that was resolved at-scene by EMS ambulance clinicians.
“低血糖可再发(HS2)”是一种实用的基于传单的转诊干预措施,专为接受过低血糖治疗并成功治疗的急诊医疗服务(EMS)临床医生设计。其主要目的是鼓励收件人与他们的全科医生或糖尿病护士联系,以便对他们的糖尿病进行医疗管理的改进,从而降低他们再次发生低血糖的风险。在此,我们为增量分析构建了一个新的经济模型,以便在 2018-19 年的价格下,从英国国家医疗服务体系(NHS)的角度比较 HS2 与初始低血糖发作后两周内的常规护理对低血糖再发的影响。我们发现,接受 HS2 干预的患者在初始低血糖发作后两周内,NHS 的人均费用为 49.79 英镑,而在标准护理下的人均费用为 40.50 英镑。在此期间评估的目标患者受益发现,在 HS2 下低血糖无复发的概率平均为 42.4%,在标准护理下为 39.4%,相对风险降低了 7.6%。我们发现,实施 HS2 将使 NHS 在每例低血糖复发的情况下增加 309.36 英镑的额外成本。与 Botan 等人提供的有利支持相反,我们的结论是,在目前的形式下,与标准 NHS 护理相比,HS2 干预措施在降低初始低血糖发作后两周内低血糖复发风险方面并不能有效地利用 NHS 资源,这些低血糖发作在现场由 EMS 救护车临床医生解决。