Cheng Juanjuan, Wang Qian, Yu Jin
College of Economics and Management, Northwest Agriculture and Forestry University, Yangling, 712100, China.
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2023 May;30(22):62015-62031. doi: 10.1007/s11356-023-26371-0. Epub 2023 Mar 18.
As one of the representative fruits of China, apple plays an important role in the overall agricultural production system. However, the large amount of chemical inputs in apple production has potential detrimental impacts on the environment and human health, and thus threatens the achievement of sustainable development goals. Therefore, a comprehensive evaluation of the environmental burden (EB) and human capital (refer to human lives) loss (HCL) caused by apple production system (APS) is urgently needed to suggest directions for improvement. A method widely used to measure impacts from both the use of resources and the emissions generated in the agriculture sector is the life cycle assessment (LCA). In this study, the EB and HCL caused by the APS have been determined from two phases using the LCA methodology in China. The results show that the leading cause of EB in the agricultural materials' production phase is nitrogen fertilizer (N) production, and in the farming phase is chemical fertilizer use. The top 5 major pollutants that cause potential damage to human health in APS are carbon dioxide (CO), ammonia (NH), nitrogen dioxide (NO), nitrate (NO), and sulfur oxides (SO). The human health risk (HHR) is 5.84 × 10 disability-adjusted life year to cultivate 1 ha of the apple orchard 1 year, and the corresponding HCL is about 4230 Chinese yuan (CNY). Under the scenario analysis of a 15% reduction in chemical fertilizer use and a 20% increase in organic fertilizer (mainly dried sheep dung) use, most of the environmental impact categories have a decreasing trend, and the HCL decreased by 438 CNY of 10.36%. Therefore, chemical fertilizer (especially N) is the most critical environmental hotspot in APS, and our results suggest that the replacement of chemical fertilizers by organic fertilizers is an effective solution to reduce the potential EB and HCL and improve the sustainability of the APS.
苹果作为中国的代表性水果之一,在整个农业生产体系中发挥着重要作用。然而,苹果生产中大量的化学投入对环境和人类健康具有潜在的不利影响,从而威胁到可持续发展目标的实现。因此,迫切需要对苹果生产系统(APS)造成的环境负担(EB)和人力资本(指人类生命)损失(HCL)进行综合评估,以提出改进方向。生命周期评估(LCA)是一种广泛用于衡量农业部门资源使用和排放所产生影响的方法。在本研究中,利用LCA方法从两个阶段确定了中国APS造成的EB和HCL。结果表明,农业物资生产阶段EB的主要原因是氮肥(N)生产,而种植阶段是化肥使用。APS中对人类健康造成潜在损害的前5大主要污染物是一氧化碳(CO)、氨(NH)、二氧化氮(NO)、硝酸盐(NO)和硫氧化物(SO)。种植1公顷苹果园1年的人类健康风险(HHR)为5.84×10伤残调整生命年,相应的HCL约为4230元人民币(CNY)。在化肥使用减少15%和有机肥(主要是干羊粪)使用增加20%的情景分析下,大多数环境影响类别呈下降趋势,HCL下降了438元人民币,降幅为10.36%。因此,化肥(尤其是N)是APS中最关键的环境热点,我们的结果表明,用有机肥替代化肥是减少潜在EB和HCL以及提高APS可持续性的有效解决方案。