Ernst Neil A, Baldassarre Maria Teresa
Department of Computer Science, University of Victoria, Victoria, BC Canada.
Dipartimento di Informatica, Università degli studi di Bari, Bari, Italy.
Empir Softw Eng. 2023;28(2):55. doi: 10.1007/s10664-022-10277-5. Epub 2023 Mar 11.
Registered reports are scientific publications which begin the publication process by first having the detailed research protocol, including key research questions, reviewed and approved by peers. Subsequent analysis and results are published with minimal additional review, even if there was no clear support for the underlying hypothesis, as long as the approved protocol is followed. Registered reports can prevent several questionable research practices and give early feedback on research designs. In software engineering research, registered reports were first introduced in the International Conference on Mining Software Repositories (MSR) in 2020. They are now established in three conferences and two pre-eminent journals, including this one (EMSE). We explain the motivation for registered reports, outline the way they have been implemented in software engineering, and outline some ongoing challenges for addressing high quality software engineering research.
注册报告是一种科学出版物,其出版过程首先是让详细的研究方案(包括关键研究问题)接受同行评审并获得批准。后续的分析和结果只需经过最少的额外评审即可发表,即使对基础假设没有明确支持,只要遵循已批准的方案即可。注册报告可以防止一些有问题的研究行为,并对研究设计提供早期反馈。在软件工程研究中,注册报告于2020年在国际软件仓库挖掘会议(MSR)上首次引入。它们现在已在三个会议和两本杰出期刊(包括本刊《软件工程学报》(EMSE))中确立。我们解释了注册报告的动机,概述了它们在软件工程中的实施方式,并概述了在开展高质量软件工程研究方面一些持续存在的挑战。