Solberg Marianne Trygg, Sørensen Anne Lene, Clarke Sara, Nes Andrea Aparecida Goncalves
Lovisenberg Diaconal University College, Oslo, Norway.
JMIR Med Educ. 2023 Mar 23;9:e42512. doi: 10.2196/42512.
Advanced practice nurses (APNs) are in high demand in critical care units. In Norway, APNs are educated at the master's degree level and acquire the competence to ensure the independent, safe, and effective treatment of patients in constantly and rapidly changing health situations. APNs' competence embraces expert knowledge and skills to perform complex decision-making in the clinical context; therefore, it is essential that educational institutions in nursing facilitate learning activities that ensure and improve students' achievement of the required competence. In clinical practice studies of APN education, face-to-face reflection group (FFRG) meetings, held on campus with the participation of a nurse educator and advanced practice nursing students (APNSs), are a common learning activity to improve the competence of APNSs. Although FFRG meetings stimulate APNSs' development of required competencies, they may also result in unproductive academic discussions, reduce the time that APNSs spend in clinical practice, and make it impossible for nurse preceptors (NPs) to attend the meetings, which are all challenges that need to be addressed.
This study aimed to address the challenges experienced in FFRG meetings by implementing virtual reflection group (VRG) meetings and to explore the experiences of APNSs, NPs, and nurse educators in VRG meetings as an active learning method supported by technology to stimulate students' development of the required competence to become APNs in critical care.
This study adopted a qualitative explorative design with 2 focus group interviews and used inductive content analysis to explore the collected data.
The main finding is that reflection group meetings supported by technology resulted in a better-structured active learning method. The VRG meeting design allowed APNSs to spend more time in clinical practice placements. The APNSs and NPs experienced that they participated actively and effectively in the meetings, which led to a perceived increase in competence. The APNSs also perceived an improved learning experience compared with their prior expectations.
Users perceived that the implemented novel teaching design supported by technology, the VRG meeting, was a more effective method than FFRG meetings on campus to develop APNSs' required competence in critical care. The VRG was also perceived as an improved method to solve the challenges encountered in FFRG meetings. Specifically, the APNSs felt that they were prepared to undertake complex decision-making with a higher level of analytic cognition in a clinical context and to lead professional discussions in the ward. This developed teaching design can easily be adapted to diverse educational programs at various levels of professional education.
重症监护病房对高级实践护士(APN)的需求很大。在挪威,APN接受硕士学位教育,并具备在不断快速变化的健康状况下确保独立、安全且有效地治疗患者的能力。APN的能力包括在临床环境中进行复杂决策的专业知识和技能;因此,护理教育机构开展能确保并提高学生达到所需能力的学习活动至关重要。在APN教育的临床实践研究中,由护士教育者和高级实践护理专业学生(APNS)参与在校园内举行的面对面反思小组(FFRG)会议,是提高APNS能力的常见学习活动。尽管FFRG会议促进了APNS所需能力的发展,但也可能导致学术讨论效率低下,减少APNS在临床实践中的时间,并且使护士带教老师(NP)无法参加会议,这些都是需要解决的挑战。
本研究旨在通过实施虚拟反思小组(VRG)会议来应对FFRG会议中遇到的挑战,并探索APNS、NP和护士教育者在VRG会议中的体验,VRG会议是一种由技术支持的主动学习方法,旨在促进学生发展成为重症监护领域APN所需的能力。
本研究采用定性探索性设计,进行了2次焦点小组访谈,并使用归纳式内容分析法来探索收集到的数据。
主要发现是,技术支持的反思小组会议产生了一种结构更完善的主动学习方法。VRG会议设计使APNS有更多时间进行临床实习。APNS和NP体验到他们积极有效地参与了会议,这导致他们感觉能力有所提升。与之前的预期相比,APNS也感觉到学习体验有所改善。
用户认为,实施的由技术支持的新颖教学设计——VRG会议,是一种比校园内的FFRG会议更有效的方法,可培养APNS在重症监护方面所需的能力。VRG也被视为解决FFRG会议中遇到的挑战的一种改进方法。具体而言,APNS觉得他们已准备好在临床环境中以更高水平的分析认知进行复杂决策,并在病房中主持专业讨论。这种改进后的教学设计可以轻松适应各级专业教育的不同教育项目。