Yergan J, Flood A B, LoGerfo J P, Diehr P
Department of Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle.
Med Care. 1987 Jul;25(7):592-603. doi: 10.1097/00005650-198707000-00003.
This study reviews evidence on whether services in United States hospitals vary by racial groupings of patients. The focus is on both equity and quality of hospital services. Patients with the diagnosis of pneumonia were studied at 16 randomly selected hospitals. The services and outcomes studied include five measures of the intensity of diagnostic and therapeutic services received by patients, and death rates during hospitalization. Multiple regression was used to control for patient health status at the time of entry into the hospital. Results are presented both before and after controlling for the effects of differences in the services offered between hospitals and patient payment sources. Our findings suggest that nonwhite pneumonia patients received fewer hospital services than expected on the basis of their health characteristics, and that their hospital lengths of stay were longer than expected. These findings were apparent when the hospitals were examined in aggregate and within individual institutions. No consistent differences in death rates were apparent. Possible explanations for these results are discussed. From our data, we conclude that patient race remains a potentially significant characteristic in determining the intensity of care provided to patients in hospitals, which is not explained by differences among racial groups in health status, source of payment, or site of hospitalization.
本研究回顾了关于美国医院服务是否因患者种族分组而异的证据。重点在于医院服务的公平性和质量。在16家随机选取的医院中对诊断为肺炎的患者进行了研究。所研究的服务和结果包括患者接受的诊断和治疗服务强度的五项指标,以及住院期间的死亡率。使用多元回归来控制患者入院时的健康状况。在控制了医院提供的服务差异和患者支付来源的影响之前和之后都呈现了结果。我们的研究结果表明,非白人肺炎患者接受的医院服务比根据其健康特征预期的要少,并且他们的住院时间比预期的要长。当对医院进行总体检查以及在各个机构内部检查时,这些结果都很明显。死亡率没有明显的一致差异。讨论了这些结果的可能解释。根据我们的数据,我们得出结论,患者种族仍然是决定医院向患者提供的护理强度的一个潜在重要特征,而种族群体在健康状况、支付来源或住院地点方面的差异并不能解释这一点。