Davey Kevin, Jacob Sumin, Prasad Nilesh, Shri Manjula, Amdur Richard, Blanchard Janice, Smith Jeffrey, Douglass Katherine
Department of Emergency Medicine, George Washington University, Washington, DC, United States of America.
Department of Emergency Medicine, Believer's Church Medical College Hospital, Thiruvalla, Kerala, India.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2022 Feb 11;2(2):e0000009. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0000009. eCollection 2022.
In India, and many low-middle income countries (LMICs), emergency medicine (EM) remains a poorly defined specialty and an unregulated field of clinical practice. Recognition of the attitudes, understanding, and expectations of patients presenting to Indian EDs will be crucial to the continued development of EM as a specialty. This is a multicenter, prospective, cross sectional study of adult and pediatric patients presenting to the ED in three geographically distinct regions of India. Participants were surveyed about their expectations regarding the type of care that they expected to receive, previous treatment options they have utilized, basic understanding of ED operations, factors contributing to their decision to seek ED care, and basic demographic information. 779 patients were approached to participate in the study, of which 698 (90%) completed the survey. Common ways that patients reported learning about the ED were referral from another healthcare provider (45%) and recommendation by a family member (61%). Participants chose the ED was because they thought they would be seen quickly (89%), would receive acute pain management (45%), their regular outpatient care was closed (45%), or were sent by another doctor (45%). Patients expected to wait 0.3 hours (18 minutes) on average to see a doctor in the ED. Over 75% or patients expected to see a specialist consultant in the ED and 12% expected to see their personal physician. Eighty-five percent of patients were triaged as moderate or high acuity, and 74% of patients were admitted. This study found that ED in India is utilized by a population with an extremely high acuity of medical illness that attempts to access healthcare through multiple avenues. Patients most frequently visit the ED due to a referral from another healthcare provider or family member. Most patients are aware of the existence of the ED, though understanding of available services may be lacking. Future research should focus on community outreach and education initiatives on ED services.
在印度以及许多中低收入国家(LMICs),急诊医学(EM)仍然是一个定义不明确的专业领域,也是一个缺乏规范的临床实践领域。认识到前往印度急诊科就诊患者的态度、理解和期望,对于急诊医学作为一个专业的持续发展至关重要。这是一项针对印度三个地理区域不同的急诊科成年和儿科患者的多中心、前瞻性横断面研究。对参与者进行了调查,内容涉及他们对预期接受的护理类型的期望、他们之前使用过的治疗选择、对急诊科运作的基本了解、促使他们决定前往急诊科就诊的因素以及基本人口统计信息。共有779名患者被邀请参与该研究,其中698名(90%)完成了调查。患者报告得知急诊科的常见方式是由另一位医疗服务提供者转诊(45%)以及家庭成员推荐(61%)。参与者选择急诊科的原因是他们认为会很快得到诊治(89%)、会接受急性疼痛管理(45%)、他们的常规门诊关闭了(45%)或者是被另一位医生送来的(45%)。患者预计在急诊科平均等待0.3小时(18分钟)看医生。超过75%的患者期望在急诊科见到专科顾问医生,12%的患者期望见到他们的私人医生。85%的患者被分诊为中度或高度急症,74%的患者被收治。该研究发现,印度的急诊科被患有极其严重疾病的人群所利用,这些人试图通过多种途径获得医疗服务。患者最常因另一位医疗服务提供者或家庭成员的转诊而前往急诊科。大多数患者知道急诊科的存在,尽管可能缺乏对可用服务的了解。未来的研究应侧重于针对急诊科服务的社区宣传和教育举措。