PLOS Glob Public Health. 2022 Aug 31;2(8):e0000455. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0000455. eCollection 2022.
Women in Africa are fifty times more likely than in high-income settings to die following caesarean delivery, and peripartum haemorrhage is most strongly associated with mortality. We aimed to establish consensus on which interventions are considered most feasible to implement and most effective at reducing haemorrhage associated with caesarean delivery across Africa. We conducted a Delphi consensus study, including obstetric and anaesthesia providers from across Africa. In round one the expert group proposed key interventions for consideration. In rounds two and three the interventions were ranked on a 9-point Likert scale for effectiveness and feasibility. Round four was an online discussion to establish consensus on effectiveness and feasibility of interventions for which this had not been reached in round three. Twenty-eight interventions were considered both highly effective and feasible in Africa. Interventions covered a range of fields, categorised into direct- or indirect interventions. Direct interventions included: risk assessment and screening; checklists and protocols; monitoring and surveillance; availability of resources; ability to perform technical skills. Indirect interventions included: community and maternal education; contraception and family planning; minimum training standards; referral patterns and delays; advocacy to key stakeholders; simulation and team training; and 24-hour access to safe emergency caesarean delivery. Interventions considered both effective and feasible in reducing peripartum haemorrhage associated with caesarean delivery in Africa were identified. A multi-layered implementation strategy, including immediately developing a perioperative caesarean delivery bundle of care, in addition to longer-term public health measures may have a profound impact on maternal mortality in Africa.
非洲女性剖宫产术后死亡的可能性是高收入地区女性的50倍,而产后出血与死亡率的关联最为密切。我们旨在就哪些干预措施被认为在非洲实施起来最可行且在减少剖宫产相关出血方面最有效达成共识。我们开展了一项德尔菲共识研究,纳入了来自非洲各地的产科和麻醉科医护人员。在第一轮中,专家组提出了供考虑的关键干预措施。在第二轮和第三轮中,这些干预措施按照9分制李克特量表对有效性和可行性进行排名。第四轮是一次在线讨论,以就第三轮中未达成共识的干预措施的有效性和可行性达成共识。在非洲,有28项干预措施被认为既非常有效又可行。干预措施涵盖一系列领域,分为直接干预或间接干预。直接干预包括:风险评估与筛查;检查表与规程;监测与监督;资源可用性;技术技能操作能力。间接干预包括:社区与孕产妇教育;避孕与计划生育;最低培训标准;转诊模式与延误;向关键利益相关者进行宣传;模拟与团队培训;以及24小时可获得安全的急诊剖宫产。确定了在非洲减少剖宫产相关产后出血方面既有效又可行的干预措施。一种多层次的实施策略,包括立即制定剖宫产围手术期护理综合措施,以及长期的公共卫生措施,可能会对非洲的孕产妇死亡率产生深远影响。