Vanden Bussche Alicia B, Haug Nancy A, Ball Tali Manber, Padula Claudia B, Goldstein-Pierarski Andrea N, Williams Leanne M
Palo Alto University, 1791 Arastradero Rd., Palo Alto, CA 94304, USA.
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Stanford University School of Medicine, 401 Quarry Rd., Palo Alto, CA 94304, USA.
Pers Med Psychiatry. 2017 Jul;3:30-37. doi: 10.1016/j.pmip.2017.04.001. Epub 2017 May 16.
Recent research recognizes considerable overlap in the clinical presentation of psychiatric disorders such as Autism Spectrum Disorder, Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder and Social Anxiety Disorder. The diagnostic approach collects symptoms to reflect a single underlying psychopathological process. The Research Domain Criteria (RDoC) emphasizes psychopathology as arising from combinations of abnormalities in core underlying constructs that can be measured at many levels of analysis, from biological to behavioral. Patients who present with clinical heterogeneity may benefit from transdiagnostic case conceptualization that integrates detailed symptom information across multiple measurements spanning multiple domains of functioning based in the RDoC framework.
We report on one case that was included in a research study focused on advancing knowledge towards a transdiagnostic, brain-based model of anxiety and depression. The 20-year-old male patient presented at a community mental health clinic for inattention, low mood, sleep problems and anxious symptoms. The patient also presented with primary problems in negative valence systems (anxiety, avoidance, and bias towards negative information), cognitive systems (fluctuating cognitive ability over time, poor concentration and ability to focus), and social processing systems (deficits in social communication skills). Conceptualizing this case through a transdiagnostic lens augmented the patient's treatment plan by including a more integrative approach. Treatment included social skills training, progressive relaxation exercises, and basic psychoeducation in emotional expression and independent living skills.
This case illustrates the utility of a transdiagnostic approach, particularly when a traditional diagnostic model generates conflicting evidence and/or multiple comorbidities. RDoC provides a framework for integrating abnormalities across multiple dimensions. Furthermore, it lays the foundation for future integration of brain-behavior relationships into case conceptualization and personalized treatment approaches.
近期研究发现,诸如自闭症谱系障碍、注意力缺陷多动障碍和社交焦虑障碍等精神疾病在临床表现上存在相当大的重叠。诊断方法收集症状以反映单一潜在的心理病理过程。研究领域标准(RDoC)强调心理病理学源于核心潜在结构异常的组合,这些异常可在从生物学到行为学的多个分析层面进行测量。表现出临床异质性的患者可能受益于跨诊断病例概念化,该方法基于RDoC框架,整合跨多个功能领域的多次测量的详细症状信息。
我们报告了一个纳入一项研究的病例,该研究旨在推进对焦虑和抑郁的跨诊断、基于大脑模型的认识。这位20岁的男性患者因注意力不集中、情绪低落、睡眠问题和焦虑症状就诊于社区心理健康诊所。患者在负性效价系统(焦虑、回避以及对负面信息的偏向)、认知系统(认知能力随时间波动、注意力不集中和难以集中注意力)以及社会加工系统(社交沟通技能缺陷)方面也存在原发性问题。通过跨诊断视角对该病例进行概念化,采用更综合的方法完善了患者的治疗方案。治疗包括社交技能训练、渐进性放松练习以及情绪表达和独立生活技能方面的基础心理教育。
该病例说明了跨诊断方法的实用性,特别是当传统诊断模型产生相互矛盾的证据和/或多种合并症时。RDoC提供了一个整合多个维度异常的框架。此外,它为未来将脑-行为关系整合到病例概念化和个性化治疗方法奠定了基础。