Discipline of Psychiatry and Mental Health, School of Clinical Medicine, University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia.
ForLikeMinds, New York City, NY, USA.
Int J Soc Psychiatry. 2023 Sep;69(6):1472-1480. doi: 10.1177/00207640231164285. Epub 2023 Mar 28.
Caregivers have a key role in providing social and practical support for individuals with bipolar disorder. As such, their perspectives are uniquely important when collaborative decisions are made on management priorities and potential treatment options.
This study aims to identify common concerns that caregivers have in the management of an individual with a bipolar disorder.
111 caregivers were recruited from online advertisements and social media support groups. They completed a questionnaire that obtained demographic and clinical feature details, in addition to whether a series of generic and phase-specific (i.e. depressive or hypo/manic) management concerns reflected their experiences of caregiving.
Concerns about work capacity and family impacts were almost ubiquitous, as were general feelings of ineffectiveness and irritation. Depressive phases were more likely to elicit fears of suicide by caregivers, while during hypo/manic phases caregivers were more likely to be angered, have concerns for their own safety, call emergency services or to take safety precautions. There were no differences between bipolar subtypes with regards to concerns during depressive phases, but concerns around safety, reputational damage and risky behaviours were more likely in relation to those experiencing bipolar I manic phases compared to bipolar II hypomanic phases.
The concerns identified by caregivers in this paper are consistent with clinical expectations, with concerns regarding insularity and externalisation being prominent for depression and hypo/mania respectively. Not all of these caregivers' concerns would necessarily be communicated in a healthcare setting, highlighting the need for an embracive approach to improve management outcomes. Additionally, caregivers' emphasis on their distinctive altruistic concerns highlights their commitment to care despite the challenges, and thus further highlights the potential for clinicians to implement a more proactive role for them in patient care.
在为双相情感障碍患者提供社会和实际支持方面,护理人员发挥着关键作用。因此,在就管理重点和潜在治疗方案做出协作决策时,他们的观点具有独特的重要性。
本研究旨在确定护理人员在管理双相情感障碍患者时共同关注的问题。
从在线广告和社交媒体支持小组中招募了 111 名护理人员。他们完成了一份问卷,其中包括人口统计学和临床特征的详细信息,以及一系列通用和特定阶段(即抑郁或轻躁狂/躁狂)的管理问题是否反映了他们的护理经验。
几乎所有护理人员都对工作能力和家庭影响表示担忧,同时普遍感到无力和恼怒。在抑郁阶段,护理人员更有可能担心患者自杀,而在轻躁狂/躁狂阶段,护理人员更有可能感到愤怒、担心自己的安全、拨打紧急服务电话或采取安全预防措施。在抑郁阶段,双相情感障碍的亚型之间没有差异,但在经历双相 I 型躁狂阶段时,护理人员更有可能担心安全、名誉受损和危险行为,而在经历双相 II 型轻躁狂阶段时则不太可能。
本文中护理人员确定的关注点与临床预期一致,在抑郁阶段关注孤立和外化,在轻躁狂/躁狂阶段分别关注这两个问题。并非所有这些护理人员的关注点都会在医疗保健环境中得到传达,这凸显了需要采取包容的方法来改善管理结果。此外,护理人员强调他们独特的利他主义关注点,突显了他们在面临挑战时对护理的承诺,因此进一步凸显了临床医生在患者护理中为他们发挥更积极作用的潜力。