Bland R, Orn H
Can J Psychiatry. 1986 Mar;31(2):129-37. doi: 10.1177/070674378603100210.
The relationship between family violence and psychiatric disorders was examined using standardized diagnostic interviews of 1200 randomly selected residents of a large Canadian city. The results showed that higher than expected proportions of those exhibiting violent behavior had a psychiatric diagnosis and the rate of violent behaviors in those with diagnoses (54.4%) significantly (p less than .0001) exceeds the rate in the remainder of the sample (15.5%). Particularly high rates of violence are found in those where alcoholism is combined with antisocial personality disorder and/or recurrent depression (80-93%). Also at high risk for violence are those who have made suicide attempts (over 50%) and those who have been arrested for non-traffic offences (two-thirds). These data suggest that psychiatric disorders have a strong relationship to violent behavior, and are not in agreement with the predominantly sociological explanations of family violence.
通过对加拿大一个大城市随机抽取的1200名居民进行标准化诊断访谈,研究了家庭暴力与精神疾病之间的关系。结果显示,表现出暴力行为的人群中,患有精神疾病诊断的比例高于预期,且患有诊断疾病的人群中暴力行为发生率(54.4%)显著(p<0.0001)超过样本其余部分的发生率(15.5%)。在酗酒合并反社会人格障碍和/或复发性抑郁症的人群中,暴力发生率尤其高(80 - 93%)。有自杀企图的人群(超过50%)以及因非交通罪行被捕的人群(三分之二)也处于暴力的高风险中。这些数据表明,精神疾病与暴力行为有很强的关联,这与主要基于社会学的家庭暴力解释不一致。