Long Yicheng, Liu Xiawei, Liu Zhening
Department of Psychiatry, and National Clinical Research Center for Mental Disorders, The Second Xiangya Hospital, Central South University, Changsha 410011, China.
Brain Sci. 2023 Mar 1;13(3):429. doi: 10.3390/brainsci13030429.
Based on functional magnetic resonance imaging and multilayer dynamic network model, the brain network's quantified temporal stability has shown potential in predicting altered brain functions. This manuscript aims to summarize current knowledge, clinical research progress, and future perspectives on brain network's temporal stability. There are a variety of widely used measures of temporal stability such as the variance/standard deviation of dynamic functional connectivity strengths, the temporal variability, the flexibility (switching rate), and the temporal clustering coefficient, while there is no consensus to date which measure is the best. The temporal stability of brain networks may be associated with several factors such as sex, age, cognitive functions, head motion, circadian rhythm, and data preprocessing/analyzing strategies, which should be considered in clinical studies. Multiple common psychiatric disorders such as schizophrenia, major depressive disorder, and bipolar disorder have been found to be related to altered temporal stability, especially during the resting state; generally, both excessively decreased and increased temporal stabilities were thought to reflect disorder-related brain dysfunctions. However, the measures of temporal stability are still far from applications in clinical diagnoses for neuropsychiatric disorders partly because of the divergent results. Further studies with larger samples and in transdiagnostic (including schizoaffective disorder) subjects are warranted.
基于功能磁共振成像和多层动态网络模型,脑网络的量化时间稳定性已显示出预测脑功能改变的潜力。本手稿旨在总结关于脑网络时间稳定性的当前知识、临床研究进展及未来展望。有多种广泛使用的时间稳定性测量方法,如动态功能连接强度的方差/标准差、时间变异性、灵活性(切换率)和时间聚类系数,然而迄今为止尚无关于哪种测量方法最佳的共识。脑网络的时间稳定性可能与多个因素相关,如性别、年龄、认知功能、头部运动、昼夜节律以及数据预处理/分析策略,这些在临床研究中都应予以考虑。已发现多种常见精神疾病,如精神分裂症、重度抑郁症和双相情感障碍,都与时间稳定性改变有关,尤其是在静息状态下;一般来说,时间稳定性过度降低和升高都被认为反映了与疾病相关的脑功能障碍。然而,时间稳定性测量方法距离应用于神经精神疾病的临床诊断仍有很大差距,部分原因是结果存在分歧。有必要开展更大样本量以及跨诊断(包括分裂情感性障碍)受试者的进一步研究。