Mental Health Service Line, Veterans Affairs Medical Center, White River Junction, VT 05009, USA.
Department of Psychiatry and Dartmouth Institute, Geisel School of Medicine, Dartmouth College, Hanover, NH 03755, USA.
Mil Med. 2023 Aug 29;188(9-10):e3173-e3181. doi: 10.1093/milmed/usad088.
Veteran patients have access to a broad range of health care services in the Veterans' Health Administration (VHA). There are concerns, however, that all Veteran patients may not have access to timely care. The Maintaining Internal Systems and Strengthening Integrated Outside Networks Act was passed in 2018 to ensure that eligible Veterans can receive timely, high-quality care. The Maintaining Internal Systems and Strengthening Integrated Outside Networks Act makes use of Department of Veterans Affairs (VA)-contracted care to achieve its goal. There are concerns, however, that these transitions of care may, in fact, place Veterans at a higher risk of poor health outcomes. This is a particular concern with regard to suicide prevention. No study has investigated suicide-related safety events in Veteran patients who receive care in VA-contracted community care settings.
A retrospective analysis of root-cause analysis (RCA) reports and patient safety reports of suicide-related safety events that involved VA-contracted community care was conducted. Events that were reported to the VHA National Center for Patient Safety between January 1, 2018, and June 30, 2022, were included. A coding book was developed to abstract relevant variables from each report, for example, report type and facility and patient characteristics. Root causes reported in RCAs were also coded, and the factors that contributed to the events were described in the patient safety reports. Two reviewers independently coded 10 cases, and we then calculated a kappa. Because the kappa was greater than 80% (i.e. 89.2%), one reviewer coded the remaining cases.
Among 139 potentially eligible reports, 88 reports were identified that met the study inclusion criteria. Of these 88 reports, 62.5% were patient safety reports and 37.5% were RCA reports. There were 129 root causes of suicide-related safety events involving VA-contracted community care. Most root causes were because of health care-related processes. Reports cited concerns around challenges with communication and deficiencies in mental health treatment. A few reports also described concerns that community care providers were not available to engage in patient safety activities. Patient safety reports voiced similar concerns but also pointed to specific issues with the safety of the environment, for example, access to methods of strangulation in community care treatment settings in an emergency room or a rehabilitation unit.
It is important to strengthen the systems of care across VHA- and VA-contracted community care settings to reduce the risk of suicide in Veteran patients. This includes developing standardized methods to improve the safety of the clinical environment as well as implementing robust methods to facilitate communication between VHA and community care providers. In addition, Veteran patients may benefit from quality and safety activities that capitalize on the collective knowledge of VHA- and VA-contracted community care organizations.
退伍军人在退伍军人事务部 (VA) 可以获得广泛的医疗服务。然而,有人担心并非所有退伍军人都能及时获得护理。2018 年通过了《维护内部系统和加强综合外部网络法案》,以确保符合条件的退伍军人能够及时获得高质量的护理。《维护内部系统和加强综合外部网络法案》利用退伍军人事务部的合同护理来实现这一目标。然而,有人担心这些护理的过渡实际上会使退伍军人面临更糟糕的健康结果的风险。这在预防自杀方面尤其令人担忧。没有研究调查过在退伍军人事务部合同社区护理中接受护理的退伍军人患者与自杀相关的安全事件。
对涉及退伍军人事务部合同社区护理的自杀相关安全事件的根本原因分析 (RCA) 报告和患者安全报告进行了回顾性分析。报告包括 2018 年 1 月 1 日至 2022 年 6 月 30 日期间向退伍军人事务部国家患者安全中心报告的事件。制定了一个编码手册,从每份报告中提取相关变量,例如报告类型和设施以及患者特征。还对 RCA 中报告的根本原因进行了编码,并在患者安全报告中描述了导致事件的因素。两名审查员独立对 10 例进行了编码,然后计算了 kappa 值。由于 kappa 值大于 80%(即 89.2%),因此仅由一名审查员对其余病例进行了编码。
在 139 份潜在合格报告中,确定了 88 份符合研究纳入标准的报告。在这 88 份报告中,62.5%是患者安全报告,37.5%是 RCA 报告。涉及退伍军人事务部合同社区护理的自杀相关安全事件有 129 个根本原因。大多数根本原因是医疗相关流程造成的。报告提到了沟通方面的挑战和心理健康治疗方面的缺陷。少数报告还描述了对社区护理提供者无法参与患者安全活动的担忧。患者安全报告也表达了类似的担忧,但也指出了环境安全方面的具体问题,例如在紧急情况或康复单元中,社区护理治疗环境中是否可以获得窒息方法。
加强退伍军人事务部和退伍军人事务部合同社区护理环境中的护理系统对于降低退伍军人自杀风险非常重要。这包括制定标准化方法以提高临床环境的安全性,并实施强有力的方法来促进退伍军人事务部和社区护理提供者之间的沟通。此外,退伍军人患者可能会从利用退伍军人事务部和退伍军人事务部合同社区护理组织的集体知识的质量和安全活动中受益。