Mayne John
Independent Consultant, Canada.
Eval Program Plann. 2023 Jun;98:102276. doi: 10.1016/j.evalprogplan.2023.102276. Epub 2023 Mar 18.
This paper argues that assumptions in a theory of change are the causal connections, events, and conditions that need to be realized for the intervention to work. Using an example of an intervention aimed at improving educational outcomes for girls in a conservative region, two kinds of assumptions are discussed: cause-effect assumptions and causal-link assumptions. Implications for the use of theories of change, including their use in setting causality and the utility of evidence in argument for learning about and testing assumptions are also discussed. The need for an explicit description of what is meant by the term 'assumptions' in association with a theory of change is also highlighted.
本文认为,变革理论中的假设是干预措施发挥作用所需实现的因果联系、事件和条件。以一项旨在改善保守地区女童教育成果的干预措施为例,讨论了两种假设:因果假设和因果联系假设。还讨论了变革理论的应用意义,包括其在确定因果关系方面的应用以及证据在论证学习和检验假设中的效用。文中还强调了与变革理论相关的“假设”一词需要有明确的定义。