Qin Xiaokuan, Sun Kai, Ao Yingfang, Liu Jianping, Wang Mei, Deng Qiang, Zhong Weihong, Liu Jun, Sun Shaoqiu, Liu Xiangdi, Shi Bin, Guan Xuefeng, Du Shuangqing, Zou Jun, Wu Chengliang, Chen Feng, Fang Yigong, Nie Xiaoyan, Mo Wen, Guo Jiayi, Zhang Yili, Dong Yan, Wei Xu, Zhu Liguo
Department of Spine, Wangjing Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing, China.
Beijing Key Laboratory of Sports Injuries, Institute of Sports Medicine, Peking University Third Hospital, Beijing, China.
J Evid Based Med. 2023 Jun;16(2):246-258. doi: 10.1111/jebm.12530. Epub 2023 Apr 5.
Frozen shoulder is a common disorder that can lead to long-lasting impairment in shoulder-related daily activities. Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) has played an important role in the effort to manage frozen shoulder.
We aimed to develop an evidence-based guideline for treating frozen shoulder with traditional Chinese medicine.
Evidence-based guideline.
We developed this guideline based on internationally recognized and accepted guideline standards. The guideline development group used the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) approach to rate the certainty of evidence and the strength of recommendations. The benefits and harms, resources, accessibility, and other factors were fully taken into account, and the GRADE grid method was used to reach consensus on all recommendations.
We established a multidisciplinary guideline development panel. Based on a systematic literature search and a face-to-face meeting, nine clinical questions were identified. Finally, twelve recommendations were reached by consensus, comprehensively considering the balance of benefits and harms, certainty of evidence, costs, clinical feasibility, accessibility, and clinical acceptability.
This guideline panel made twelve recommendations, which covered the use of manual therapy, acupuncture, needle knife, Cheezheng Xiaotong plaster, Gutong plaster, exercise therapy and integrated TCM and Western medicine, such as combined modalities and corticosteroid injections. Most of them were weakly recommended or consensus based. The users of this guideline are most likely to be clinicians and health administrators.
肩周炎是一种常见疾病,可导致肩部相关日常活动长期受损。中医在肩周炎的治疗中发挥了重要作用。
我们旨在制定一份基于证据的中医治疗肩周炎指南。
基于证据的指南。
我们根据国际认可和接受的指南标准制定本指南。指南制定小组采用推荐意见评估、制定与评价分级(GRADE)方法对证据的确定性和推荐意见的强度进行评级。充分考虑了利弊、资源、可及性和其他因素,并使用GRADE网格法就所有推荐意见达成共识。
我们成立了一个多学科指南制定小组。基于系统的文献检索和面对面会议,确定了九个临床问题。最后,综合考虑利弊平衡、证据确定性、成本、临床可行性、可及性和临床可接受性,经共识达成了十二条推荐意见。
本指南小组提出了十二条推荐意见,涵盖了手法治疗、针灸、针刀、蠲痹消痛膏、骨痛膏、运动疗法以及中西医结合,如联合治疗方式和皮质类固醇注射等的应用。其中大多数为弱推荐或基于共识。本指南的使用者最有可能是临床医生和卫生管理人员。