Raymakers J A, Hoekstra O, van Putten J, Kerkhoff H, Duursma S A
Skeletal Radiol. 1986;15(3):191-7. doi: 10.1007/BF00354059.
In 174 adults presenting with backache, bone densitometry was performed on the lumbar spine, both femoral necks, and one femoral shaft employing dual energy photon absorptiometry (DPA); in 112 of these, densitometry was undertaken on L4 using single energy quantitative computer assisted tomography (CT). Radiographs of the spine were obtained in all patients and those with known or suspected malignant disease were excluded. The subjects were divided into two groups according to the presence (n = 128) or absence (n = 44) of signs of vertebral collapse or compression. The predictive value of the densitometric results for the presence of vertebral fractures was calculated and used as an estimate of fracture risk. While CT showed somewhat higher predictive values than DPA of the spine or combinations of DPA results from spine and femoral necks, the difference was not significant. It is concluded that with both CT and DPA the probability of the presence or absence of fracture can be raised to 75-80% when the probability prior to the investigation is 50% and when the threshold values of the measurements are chosen so that their sensitivity and specificity are about equal.
对174例背痛成人患者,采用双能光子吸收法(DPA)对腰椎、双侧股骨颈和一侧股骨干进行骨密度测定;其中112例患者采用单能定量计算机辅助断层扫描(CT)对L4进行骨密度测定。所有患者均拍摄了脊柱X线片,排除已知或疑似恶性疾病患者。根据是否存在椎体塌陷或压缩迹象,将研究对象分为两组,存在该迹象的128例为一组,不存在该迹象的44例为另一组。计算骨密度测定结果对椎体骨折存在情况的预测价值,并将其作为骨折风险的评估指标。虽然CT显示出的预测价值略高于脊柱DPA或脊柱与股骨颈DPA结果的组合,但差异并不显著。得出结论,当检查前骨折概率为50%,且选择测量阈值使其敏感性和特异性大致相等时,使用CT和DPA均可将骨折存在或不存在的概率提高到75% - 80%。