Betts Juliana M, Weinman Aaron L, Oliver Jane, Braddick Maxwell, Huang Siyu, Nguyen Matthew, Miller Adrian, Tong Steven Y C, Gibney Katherine B
School of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, Monash University, Melbourne, Australia.
Department of Infectious Diseases, University of Melbourne at the Peter Doherty Institute for Infection and Immunity, Melbourne, Australia.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2023 Apr 13;3(4):e0001294. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0001294. eCollection 2023.
More than 50 million influenza infections and over 100,000 deaths from influenza occur annually. While Indigenous populations experience an inequitable influenza burden, the magnitude of this inequity has not previously been estimated on a global scale. This study compared rates of influenza-associated hospitalisation and mortality between Indigenous and non-Indigenous populations globally.
A systematic review and meta-analysis was conducted including literature published prior to 13 July 2021. Eligible articles either reported a rate ratio (RR) comparing laboratory-confirmed influenza-associated hospitalisation and/or mortality between an Indigenous population and a corresponding benchmark population, or reported sufficient information for this to be calculated using publicly available data. Findings were reported by country/region and pooled by country and period (pandemic/seasonal) when multiple studies were available using a random-effects model. The I2 statistic assessed variability between studies.
Thirty-six studies (moderate/high quality) were included; all from high or high-middle income countries. The pooled influenza-associated hospitalisation RR (HRR) for indigenous compared to benchmark populations was 5·7 (95% CI: 2·7-12·0) for Canada, 5·2 (2.9-9.3) for New Zealand, and 5.2 (4.2-6.4) for Australia. Of the Australian studies, the pooled HRR for seasonal influenza was 3.1 (2·7-3·5) and for pandemic influenza was 6·2 (5·1-7·5). Heterogeneity was slightly higher among studies of pandemic influenza than seasonal influenza. The pooled mortality RR was 4.1 (3·0-5.7) in Australia and 3·3 (2.7-4.1) in the United States.
Ethnic inequities in severe influenza persist and must be addressed by reducing disparities in the underlying determinants of health. Influenza surveillance systems worldwide should include Indigenous status to determine the extent of the disease burden among Indigenous populations. Ethnic inequities in pandemic influenza illustrate the need to prioritise Indigenous populations in pandemic response plans.
每年有超过5000万例流感感染病例,并有超过10万人死于流感。虽然原住民群体承受着不公平的流感负担,但此前尚未在全球范围内对这种不公平的程度进行估计。本研究比较了全球原住民和非原住民群体中与流感相关的住院率和死亡率。
进行了一项系统评价和荟萃分析,纳入了2021年7月13日前发表的文献。符合条件的文章要么报告了比较原住民群体和相应对照群体之间实验室确诊的与流感相关的住院率和/或死亡率的率比(RR),要么报告了足够的信息以便使用公开数据进行计算。研究结果按国家/地区报告,当有多篇研究时,按国家和时期(大流行/季节性)使用随机效应模型进行汇总。I²统计量评估研究之间的异质性。
纳入了36项研究(中等/高质量);均来自高收入或高中等收入国家。与对照群体相比,加拿大原住民的流感相关住院合并率比(HRR)为5.7(95%CI:2.7 - 12.0),新西兰为5.2(2.9 - 9.3),澳大利亚为5.2(4.2 - 6.4)。在澳大利亚的研究中,季节性流感的合并HRR为3.1(2.7 - 3.5),大流行性流感为6.2(5.1 - 7.5)。大流行性流感研究中的异质性略高于季节性流感研究。澳大利亚的合并死亡率RR为4.1(3.0 - 5.7),美国为3.3(2.7 - 4.1)。
严重流感方面的种族不平等现象持续存在,必须通过减少健康潜在决定因素方面的差距来加以解决。全球流感监测系统应纳入原住民身份信息,以确定原住民群体中的疾病负担程度。大流行性流感中的种族不平等表明有必要在大流行应对计划中优先考虑原住民群体。