Department of Psychology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario M5S 3G3, Canada.
Department of Psychology, Emory University, Atlanta, Georgia 30322.
J Neurosci. 2023 May 24;43(21):3849-3859. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0159-23.2023. Epub 2023 Apr 13.
A defining feature of children's cognition is the especially slow development of their attention. Despite a rich behavioral literature characterizing the development of attention, little is known about how developing attentional abilities modulate neural representations in children. This information is critical to understanding how attentional development shapes the way children process information. One possibility is that attention might be less likely to shape neural representations in children as compared with adults. In particular, representations of attended items may be less likely to be enhanced relative to unattended items. To investigate this possibility, we measured brain activity using fMRI while children (seven to nine years; male and female) and adults (21-31 years; male and female) performed a one-back task in which they were directed to attend to either motion direction or an object in a display where both were present. We used multivoxel pattern analysis to compare decoding accuracy of attended and unattended information. Consistent with attentional enhancement, we found higher decoding accuracy for task-relevant information (i.e., objects in the object-attended condition) than for task-irrelevant information (i.e., motion in the object-attended condition) in adults' visual cortices. However, in children's visual cortices, both task-relevant and task-irrelevant information were decoded equally well. What is more, whole-brain analysis showed that the children represented task-irrelevant information more than adults in multiple regions across the brain, including the prefrontal cortex. These findings show that (1) attention does not modulate neural representations in the child visual cortex, and (2) developing brains can, and do, represent more information than mature brains. Children have been shown to struggle with maintaining their attention to specific information, and at the same time, can show better learning of "distractors." While these are critical properties of childhood, their underlying neural mechanisms are unknown. To fill in this critical knowledge gap, we explored how attention shapes what is represented in children's and adults' brains using fMRI while both were asked to focus on just one of two things (objects and motion). We found that unlike adults, who prioritize the information they were asked to focus on, children represent both what they were asked to prioritize and what they were asked to ignore. This shows that attention has a fundamentally different impact on children's neural representations.
儿童认知的一个显著特点是他们的注意力发展特别缓慢。尽管有丰富的行为文献描述了注意力的发展,但对于发展中的注意力能力如何调节儿童的神经表征知之甚少。这些信息对于理解注意力发展如何塑造儿童处理信息的方式至关重要。一种可能性是,与成年人相比,注意力可能不太可能塑造儿童的神经表征。特别是,与未被注意的项目相比,被注意项目的表示可能不太可能被增强。为了研究这种可能性,我们使用 fMRI 测量了儿童(7 至 9 岁;男性和女性)和成年人(21 至 31 岁;男性和女性)的大脑活动,他们在一项 1 回任务中执行任务,要求他们注意运动方向或显示中的一个物体,两者都存在。我们使用多体素模式分析来比较被注意和未被注意信息的解码准确性。与注意力增强一致,我们发现成年人的视觉皮层中,与任务相关的信息(即物体在物体被注意的条件下)的解码准确性高于与任务无关的信息(即物体在物体被注意的条件下的运动)。然而,在儿童的视觉皮层中,任务相关和任务无关的信息都被解码得一样好。更重要的是,全脑分析显示,与成年人相比,儿童在大脑多个区域中表示任务无关的信息更多,包括前额叶皮层。这些发现表明:(1)注意力不会调节儿童视觉皮层中的神经表征;(2)发育中的大脑可以并且确实比成熟的大脑表示更多的信息。儿童在保持对特定信息的注意力方面一直存在困难,同时可以更好地学习“干扰物”。虽然这些是儿童期的关键特征,但它们的潜在神经机制尚不清楚。为了填补这一关键知识空白,我们使用 fMRI 探索了在要求儿童和成年人只关注两件事(物体和运动)中的一件时,注意力如何塑造他们的大脑中的信息。我们发现,与成年人不同,成年人优先考虑他们被要求关注的信息,而儿童则表示他们被要求优先考虑的信息和他们被要求忽略的信息。这表明注意力对儿童的神经表征有根本不同的影响。