Department of Urology, Mayo Clinic Arizona, 5777 E Mayo Blvd, Phoenix, AZ, 85054, USA.
Department of Urology, University of California-San Diego, San Diego, CA, USA.
Urolithiasis. 2023 Apr 15;51(1):70. doi: 10.1007/s00240-023-01439-1.
In 2018, the Endourology Disease Group for Excellence (EDGE) published a prospective trial comparing dusting versus basketing during ureteroscopy. One hundred fifty-nine patients were included in the original analysis, which found no difference in stone-free rate at 3 months. We report the intermediate and long-term outcomes of patients included in the original trial. Two analyses were performed. At 1-year, a retrospective chart review was performed, and data collected on stone episodes, Emergency Department (ED) visits, hospital admissions and surgical interventions. To obtain long-term outcomes, the four sites with the largest initial accrual were included in a second phase of data collection with updated analyses. The patients from those sites were contacted, re-consented, and data were collected on stone surgical interventions, stone episodes, stone recurrences on imaging, emergency department (ED) visits, and hospital admissions for stone-related care since their original procedure. One-year follow-up data were collected in 111 of the original 159 (69.8%) patients from the nine sites. There were no statistically significant differences in the number of painful episodes, ED visits, hospital admissions, or surgical interventions. 94 patients from four sites were included in the long-term analysis. There were no statistically significant differences in surgical interventions, painful stone episodes, stone recurrence on imaging, ED visits or hospitalizations for stone-related events between the two groups. Long-term outcomes of dusting versus basketing during ureteroscopy indicate that there are no significant differences in clinical outcomes between the two surgical modalities.
2018 年,腔内泌尿外科学卓越成就(EDG)组织发表了一项前瞻性试验,比较了输尿管镜检查中撒粉法与篮筐法的效果。原始分析纳入了 159 例患者,结果显示 3 个月时结石清除率无差异。我们报告了原始试验中纳入患者的中期和长期结果。进行了两项分析。在 1 年时,进行了回顾性图表审查,并收集了结石发作、急诊科 (ED) 就诊、住院和手术干预的数据。为了获得长期结果,最初纳入患者最多的四个地点被纳入了数据收集的第二阶段,并进行了更新的分析。联系了这些地点的患者,重新获得同意,并收集了自原始手术以来结石手术干预、结石发作、影像学上的结石复发、因结石相关疾病而就诊 ED 和住院的情况。原始 159 例患者中的 111 例(69.8%)来自 9 个地点的 1 年随访数据。两组之间在疼痛发作次数、ED 就诊次数、住院次数或手术干预次数上无统计学差异。来自四个地点的 94 例患者纳入了长期分析。两组之间在手术干预、有症状的结石发作、影像学上的结石复发、ED 就诊次数或因结石相关事件而住院的次数上无统计学差异。输尿管镜检查中撒粉法与篮筐法的长期结果表明,两种手术方式的临床结果无显著差异。