Scerrati Alba, Angelini Chiara, Madoglio Alba, Lucidi Daniela, Parini Sara, Verdi Daunia, Gumbs Andrew A, Spolverato Gaya
Department of Morphology, Surgery and Experimental Medicine, University of Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy.
Department of Neurosurgery, Sant' Anna University Hospital, Ferrara, Italy.
World Neurosurg X. 2022 Oct 15;18:100149. doi: 10.1016/j.wnsx.2022.100149. eCollection 2023 Apr.
Gender inequity in surgery has increasingly been a matter of debate. Contributions of female neurosurgeons to academic medicine and societies are poorly highlighted. The aim of this study was to evaluate several aspects of the professional and work-life balance of female neurosurgeons in Italy.
Data of the female neurosurgical population were extracted from a general 83-item questionnaire administered to a total of 3242 respondents. The survey was composed of multiple-choice questions investigating demographics, surgical training and practice, satisfaction, mentorship, discrimination, and harassment.
A total of 98 female neurosurgeons were included. Most responders were married or cohabiting (49%). Thirty-nine (43%) were planning to have children, and 15 of them (44%) stated the reason they still didn't have any was because of professional constraints. Seventy (71%) women were neurosurgeons with an academic position (residents or academics) and 28 (29%) were full-time attendings. Most of the female neurosurgeons are satisfied with their work: sometimes (35%), often (20%), and always or almost always (20%). Most of them (45%) stated they are rarely victims of harassment, but 66% think that they are treated differently because they are women. A similar rate for a poor and fulfilling work-life balance (34% and 35%, respectively) was detected. The majority of participants (89%) had encountered a role model during their career, but in only 11% of cases was that person female.
Even though the rate of satisfaction among female neurosurgeons in Italy is high, some of them experienced gender discrimination, including incidents of sexual harassment and microaggressions. Policies including job sharing paradigms, consistent and meaningful options for parental leave, mentorship programs, equal and fair remuneration for equal work, and zero tolerance for harassment should be encouraged.
外科领域的性别不平等问题日益成为争论焦点。女性神经外科医生对学术医学及社会的贡献鲜有突出体现。本研究旨在评估意大利女性神经外科医生在职业及工作与生活平衡方面的若干情况。
女性神经外科从业者的数据取自一份共83项问题的通用调查问卷,该问卷面向总计3242名受访者发放。调查由多项选择题构成,内容涉及人口统计学信息、外科培训与实践、满意度、导师指导、歧视及骚扰等方面。
共纳入98名女性神经外科医生。大多数受访者已婚或同居(49%)。39人(43%)计划要孩子,其中15人(44%)表示尚未生育的原因是职业限制。70名(71%)女性为担任学术职位的神经外科医生(住院医师或学者),28名(29%)为全职主治医师。大多数女性神经外科医生对工作感到满意:有时满意(35%)、经常满意(20%)、总是或几乎总是满意(20%)。她们中大多数人(45%)表示很少遭受骚扰,但66%的人认为因其女性身份而受到不同对待。工作与生活平衡状况不佳及良好的比例相近(分别为34%和35%)。大多数参与者(89%)在职业生涯中遇到过榜样人物,但其中只有11%是女性。
尽管意大利女性神经外科医生的满意度较高,但她们中的一些人仍经历了性别歧视,包括性骚扰和微侵犯事件。应鼓励推行包括工作分担模式、一致且有意义的育儿假选择、导师指导计划、同工同酬以及对骚扰零容忍等政策。