Lesch Matthew, McCambridge Jim
Department of Health Sciences, Mental Health and Addiction Research Group, University of York, York, UK.
Reg Fed Stud. 2021 Jun 3;33(2):163-185. doi: 10.1080/13597566.2021.1934454. eCollection 2023.
This study investigates how processes of horizontal policy transfer can unfold in the context of devolution, examining the development of legislation on minimum unit pricing (MUP) in Wales, following on from Scotland's earlier policy decision. The study draws on a range of sources, including primary documents, media coverage, and interviews with policy participants. Our analysis identifies the importance of the specific character of Welsh political institutions, particularly the emphasis given to participation and consultation in policymaking. In the case of MUP, we document a process of policy-oriented learning, where policymakers made a concerted effort to draw on an assortment of expertise and experiences, including but not limited to the Scottish model. We also find that the Welsh public health policy community was well placed to support the framing of MUP and to address limitations in policy capacity. The findings hold implications for future studies of learning, devolution, and alcohol policy more generally.
本研究探讨了横向政策转移过程在权力下放背景下是如何展开的,考察了继苏格兰早期政策决定之后,威尔士最低单位定价(MUP)立法的发展情况。该研究利用了一系列资料来源,包括原始文件、媒体报道以及对政策参与者的访谈。我们的分析确定了威尔士政治机构特定性质的重要性,特别是在决策过程中对参与和协商的重视。就最低单位定价而言,我们记录了一个以政策为导向的学习过程,在此过程中,政策制定者齐心协力借鉴了各种专业知识和经验,包括但不限于苏格兰模式。我们还发现,威尔士公共卫生政策界有能力支持最低单位定价的制定,并解决政策能力方面的局限性。这些研究结果对更广泛的学习、权力下放和酒精政策的未来研究具有启示意义。