Department of Clinical Psychology, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
ARQ National Psychotrauma Centre, Diemen, The Netherlands.
PLoS One. 2023 Apr 24;18(4):e0284763. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0284763. eCollection 2023.
Commemorative events, organized in the aftermath of war or large-scale violence, can have an emotional impact on those who are attending. We examined several characteristics that might influence this impact. In a quasi-experimental pretest-posttest study, participants (n = 307) watched footage of the broadcast of the Dutch National Commemoration, in which World War II is remembered. A control group of 48 participants watched the commemoration broadcast live on Remembrance Day. They were matched for age, gender, war experience and migration background with 48 participants from the study group who watched the footage, to conduct a comparability check. We found some evidence that watching the footage was comparable to watching the commemoration live on Remembrance Day in terms of emotional response and experience of psychosocial factors. Participants in the footage sample (n = 307) responded with an increase of negative and decrease of positive emotions. Individual characteristics were limitedly related to the emotional response; posttraumatic stress symptom severity predicted increased negative emotions. Experiencing meaning making, support and, to a lesser extent, recognition through commemorating was related to experiencing more positive emotions. The findings indicate these psychosocial factors may buffer the emotional distress elicited by commemoration and contribute to important cognitive and social benefits. Practical implications are discussed.
纪念活动通常在战争或大规模暴力事件后举行,可能会对参加者产生情感影响。我们研究了一些可能影响这种影响的特征。在一项准实验前后测试研究中,参与者(n=307)观看了荷兰国家纪念活动的广播片段,该活动纪念了第二次世界大战。对照组的 48 名参与者在阵亡将士纪念日观看了现场直播的纪念活动。为了进行可比性检查,他们与研究组的 48 名参与者进行了匹配,这些参与者观看了录像,以检查年龄、性别、战争经历和移民背景的可比性。我们发现一些证据表明,观看录像与在阵亡将士纪念日观看现场直播在情绪反应和心理社会因素体验方面具有可比性。录像样本中的参与者(n=307)的反应是负面情绪增加,正面情绪减少。个体特征与情绪反应的相关性有限;创伤后应激症状严重程度预示着负面情绪增加。通过纪念活动体验到意义构建、支持,在较小程度上还体验到认可,与体验到更多的积极情绪有关。这些发现表明,这些心理社会因素可能缓冲纪念活动引起的情绪困扰,并有助于带来重要的认知和社会效益。讨论了实际意义。