Werema Chacha W, Laven Linda J, Mueller Kristina R, Laven Richard A
School of Veterinary Science, Massey University, Private Bag 11 222, Palmerston North 4442, New Zealand.
College of Veterinary Medicine and Biomedical Sciences, Sokoine University of Agriculture, Morogoro 67 115, Tanzania.
Animals (Basel). 2023 Apr 17;13(8):1372. doi: 10.3390/ani13081372.
Lameness detection is a significant challenge. Locomotion scoring (LS), the most widely used system for detecting lameness, has several limitations, including its subjective nature and the existence of multiple systems, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate whether the foot skin temperature (FST) of hind limbs, as measured using infrared thermography (IRT), could potentially be used as an alternative on Tanzanian dairy farms. Each of the three study farms were visited twice during the afternoon milking on consecutive days, with a total of 170 cows assessed. DairyNZ LS (4-point scale (0-3)) was undertaken on the first day as the cows exited the milking parlour after being milked, while on the following day, the plantar aspect of the hind limbs of the cows was thermally imaged while they were standing in the milking parlour, using a handheld T650sc forward-looking infrared camera. Mean FST was higher for cows with a locomotion score of 1 than those with a score of 0; higher for cows with a locomotion score of 2 than those with a score of 1; and higher for cows with a locomotion score of 3 than those with a score of 2, with each one-unit locomotion score increase being associated with a 0.57 °C increase in mean temperature across all zones. The optimal cut-off point of 38.0 °C for mean temperature across all zones was identified using a receiver operator characteristic curve. This cut-off point had a sensitivity of 73.2% and a specificity of 86.0% for distinguishing cows with a locomotion score ≥ 2 (clinical lameness). The prevalence of clinical lameness across all three farms was 33%, which meant that only 72% of cows with a mean FST across all zones ≥ 38.0 °C had been identified as clinically lame using LS. This study confirmed that IRT has the potential to be used to detect lameness on Tanzanian dairy farms. However, before it can be widely used, improvements in accuracy, especially specificity, are needed, as are reductions in equipment (IR camera) costs.
跛行检测是一项重大挑战。运动评分(LS)是检测跛行最广泛使用的系统,但存在若干局限性,包括其主观性以及存在多种各有优缺点的系统。因此,本研究旨在评估使用红外热成像(IRT)测量的后肢足部皮肤温度(FST)是否有可能在坦桑尼亚奶牛场用作替代方法。在连续两天的下午挤奶期间,对三个研究农场中的每个农场都进行了两次访问,共评估了170头奶牛。第一天,奶牛挤完奶后离开挤奶厅时进行了新西兰乳业协会运动评分(4分制(0 - 3)),而第二天,奶牛站在挤奶厅时,使用手持式T650sc前视红外相机对其后肢足底进行热成像。运动评分为1的奶牛的平均FST高于评分为0的奶牛;运动评分为2的奶牛高于评分为1的奶牛;运动评分为3的奶牛高于评分为2的奶牛,运动评分每增加一个单位,所有区域的平均温度升高0.57℃。使用受试者工作特征曲线确定了所有区域平均温度的最佳截止点为38.0℃。该截止点区分运动评分≥2(临床跛行)奶牛的灵敏度为73.2%,特异性为86.0%。所有三个农场临床跛行的患病率为33%,这意味着使用运动评分法,所有区域平均FST≥38.0℃的奶牛中只有72%被确定为临床跛行。本研究证实,红外热成像有潜力用于坦桑尼亚奶牛场的跛行检测。然而,在其能够被广泛使用之前,需要提高准确性,尤其是特异性,同时降低设备(红外相机)成本。