Division of Epidemiology, School of Public Health, University of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, California, United States of America.
Division of Biostatistics, School of Public Health, University of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, California, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2023 Apr 28;18(4):e0284609. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0284609. eCollection 2023.
In 2011, a historic Supreme Court decision mandated that the state of California substantially reduce its prison population to alleviate overcrowding, which was deemed so severe as to preclude the provision of adequate healthcare. To comply, California passed the Public Safety Realignment Act (Assembly Bill [AB] 109), representing the largest ever court-ordered reduction of a prison population in U.S. history. AB109 was successful in reducing the state prison population; however, although the policy was precipitated by inadequate healthcare in state prisons, no studies have examined its effects on prisoner health. As other states grapple with overcrowded prisons and look to California's experience with this landmark policy, understanding how it may have impacted prisoner health is critical. We sought to evaluate the effects of AB109 on prison mortality and assess the extent to which policy-induced changes in the age distribution of prisoners may have contributed to these effects. To do so, we used prison mortality data from the Bureau of Justice Statistics and the California Deaths in Custody reporting program and prison population data from the National Corrections Reporting Program to examine changes in overall prison mortality, the age distribution of prisoners, and age-adjusted prison mortality in California relative to other states before and after the implementation of AB109. Following AB109, California prisons experienced an increase in overall mortality relative to other states that attenuated within three years. Over the same period, California experienced a greater upward shift in the age distribution of its prisoners relative to other states, suggesting that the state's increase in overall mortality may have been driven by this change in age distribution. Indeed, when accounting for this differential change in age distribution, mortality among California prisoners exhibited a greater reduction relative to other states in the third year after implementation. As other states seek to reduce their prison populations to address overcrowding, assessments of California's experience with AB109 should consider this potential improvement in age-adjusted mortality.
2011 年,最高法院做出了一项具有历史意义的裁决,要求加利福尼亚州大幅减少监狱人口,以缓解过度拥挤的状况,因为监狱过度拥挤,以至于无法提供充分的医疗保健。为了遵守该裁决,加利福尼亚州通过了《公共安全调整法案》(AB109),这是美国历史上规模最大的一次有法院命令的监狱人口减少。AB109 成功地减少了州监狱人口;然而,尽管该政策是由州监狱医疗保健不足引发的,但没有研究考察其对囚犯健康的影响。随着其他州也在努力应对监狱过度拥挤的问题,并借鉴加利福尼亚州在这一具有里程碑意义的政策方面的经验,了解其对囚犯健康可能产生的影响至关重要。我们试图评估 AB109 对监狱死亡率的影响,并评估政策导致的囚犯年龄分布变化在多大程度上促成了这些影响。为此,我们使用了来自司法部统计局的监狱死亡率数据和加利福尼亚州羁押死亡报告计划,以及来自国家惩教报告计划的监狱人口数据,以审查加利福尼亚州在实施 AB109 前后与其他州相比,整体监狱死亡率、囚犯年龄分布以及年龄调整后监狱死亡率的变化。在 AB109 实施后,加利福尼亚州的监狱死亡率相对于其他州有所上升,但这种上升趋势在三年内逐渐减弱。同期,加利福尼亚州囚犯的年龄分布向上移动幅度大于其他州,这表明该州的整体死亡率上升可能是由这种年龄分布的变化所驱动。事实上,当考虑到这种年龄分布的差异变化时,实施后第三年,加利福尼亚州囚犯的死亡率相对于其他州有更大幅度的下降。随着其他州寻求减少监狱人口以解决过度拥挤的问题,评估加利福尼亚州实施 AB109 的经验时应考虑到这种年龄调整后死亡率的潜在改善。