Instituto Bernabeu Biotech.
Instituto Bernabeu of Fertility and Gynaecology.
Curr Opin Obstet Gynecol. 2023 Aug 1;35(4):294-299. doi: 10.1097/GCO.0000000000000881. Epub 2023 May 4.
The presence of cell-free DNA (cf-DNA) in the embryo spent culture medium allows to develop a noninvasive PGT-A (niPGTA). Noninvasive PGT-A may provide a simpler, safer and less costly approach to preimplantation genetic testing of aneuploidy (PGT-A). Furthermore, niPGTA would provide wider access to embryo genetic analysis and circumvent many legal and ethical considerations. However, the concordance rate between the results obtained by PGT-A and niPGTA varies among studies and, their clinical utility has not been already demonstrated. This review evaluates the niPGTA reliability based on SCM and adds new knowledge about the clinical relevance of SCM for noninvasive PGT-A.
The most recent concordance studies evaluating the accuracy of niPGTA using SCM showed a high variation in the informativity rate of SCM and the diagnostic concordance. Also, sensitivity and specificity showed similar heterogeneous results. Therefore, these results do not support the clinical utility of niPGTA. Regarding clinical outcome, the data are initial and further research, including randomized and nonselection studies are needed.
Further research, including randomized and nonselection studies, as well as optimization of embryo culture conditions and medium retrieval, are needed to improve the reliability and clinical utility of niPGTA.
目的综述:胚胎培养液中游离 DNA(cf-DNA)的存在使得非侵入性 PGT-A(niPGTA)得以发展。非侵入性 PGT-A 可能为非整倍体(PGT-A)的胚胎植入前遗传检测提供一种更简单、更安全、更经济的方法。此外,niPGTA 将为胚胎遗传分析提供更广泛的途径,并规避许多法律和伦理问题。然而,PGT-A 和 niPGTA 结果之间的一致性率在不同的研究中存在差异,并且其临床应用尚未得到证实。本综述基于 SCM 评估了 niPGTA 的可靠性,并增加了有关 SCM 对非侵入性 PGT-A 的临床相关性的新知识。
最新发现:最近评估使用 SCM 的 niPGTA 准确性的一致性研究表明,SCM 的信息率和诊断一致性存在很大差异。此外,敏感性和特异性也显示出相似的异质性结果。因此,这些结果不支持 niPGTA 的临床应用。关于临床结局,数据是初步的,需要进一步的研究,包括随机和非选择性研究。
总结:需要进一步的研究,包括随机和非选择性研究,以及优化胚胎培养条件和培养液的提取,以提高 niPGTA 的可靠性和临床应用。