Zilcha-Mano Sigal, Orbach Meital, Malka Michal, Lebowitz Eli R
The Department of Psychology, University of Haifa.
Child Study Center, School of Medicine, Yale University.
J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol. 2025 Mar-Apr;54(2):220-228. doi: 10.1080/15374416.2023.2188557. Epub 2023 May 11.
Two lines of research, on outcome moderators and on novel treatment targets, seek to improve the overall efficacy of child anxiety treatment, with mixed results. We propose that an integration of both lines of research can lead to improved treatment efficacy. In a first proof of concept of this approach, we studied whether the interaction between baseline levels and targeted changes in peripheral oxytocin (OT) can predict differential responses to two childhood anxiety treatments.
A total of 124 mother-child dyads participated in the study. Children's salivary OT levels were measured at baseline and again, immediately after an experimental dyadic interaction in the lab. Dyads were subsequently randomized to receive one of two treatments, differing in their targets: SPACE (Supportive Parenting for Anxious Childhood Emotions) and CBT (cognitive-behavioral therapy). Treatment outcomes were assessed using the Childhood Anxiety Related Emotional Disorders scale, reported by both mother and child.
The findings suggest that in SPACE, where the mother is the main agent of change, higher baseline levels of child OT, coupled with increases in OT following a positive mother-child interaction, predicted greater treatment efficacy. By contrast, in CBT, where the child is the main agent of change, higher baseline levels of child OT, coupled with a decrease in OT following the interaction, predicted greater treatment efficacy.
The findings highlight the importance of the integration between moderators and targets of treatments for progress toward improving treatment efficacy through precision medicine.
关于结果调节因素和新型治疗靶点的两条研究路线旨在提高儿童焦虑症治疗的总体疗效,但结果不一。我们提出,将这两条研究路线整合起来可以提高治疗效果。在这种方法的首个概念验证中,我们研究了外周催产素(OT)的基线水平与靶向变化之间的相互作用是否能够预测对两种儿童焦虑症治疗的不同反应。
共有124对母婴参与了该研究。在基线时以及在实验室进行实验性二元互动后立即再次测量儿童的唾液OT水平。随后,将二元组随机分配接受两种治疗中的一种,这两种治疗的目标不同:SPACE(针对焦虑儿童情绪的支持性养育)和CBT(认知行为疗法)。使用母亲和孩子报告的儿童焦虑相关情绪障碍量表评估治疗结果。
研究结果表明,在以母亲为主要改变因素的SPACE治疗中,儿童OT的基线水平较高,再加上积极的母婴互动后OT增加,预示着治疗效果更好。相比之下,在以孩子为主要改变因素的CBT治疗中,儿童OT的基线水平较高,再加上互动后OT减少,则预示着治疗效果更好。
这些发现凸显了治疗调节因素和靶点整合对于通过精准医学提高治疗效果的重要性。