Willoughby Melissa, Janca Emilia, Kwon Sohee, Johnston Bianca, Collins Tamlynn, Kinner Stuart A, Johns Diana, Gallant David, Glover-Wright Clare, Borschmann Rohan
The University of Melbourne, Parkville, VIC, Australia.
Murdoch Children's Research Institute, Parkville, VIC, Australia.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2024 Apr;25(2):1036-1052. doi: 10.1177/15248380231171183. Epub 2023 May 12.
Young women who have had contact with the criminal justice system (justice-involved young women) have an increased risk of being a victim of violence. However, no reviews have synthesized the evidence on interventions to prevent or respond to violence against justice-involved young women. We conducted a scoping review to identify interventions designed to prevent or respond to violence against justice-involved young women. We searched Medline, Criminal Justice Abstracts, Web of Science, and Google Scholar for peer-reviewed and gray literature published in English from January 1, 2000 until March 23, 2021. Consistent with the public health approach to violence, we included primary, secondary, and tertiary interventions. Excluding duplicates, our search returned 5,603 records, 14 of which met our inclusion criteria. We narratively synthesized the included studies, all of which were conducted in the United States. Most included studies examined a tertiary intervention ( = 10), and few examined a primary n = 2) or secondary ( = 2) intervention. Across the Joanna Briggs Institute Critical Appraisal Tools, the percentage of items met ranged from 0% to 78%. There was some limited evidence that tertiary interventions that included cognitive behavioral therapy reduced the mental health impacts of violence victimization among justice-involved young women. There was little evidence on primary and secondary interventions. Effective and evidence-based interventions to prevent violence victimization and revictimization against justice-involved young women remains a critical gap in knowledge.
与刑事司法系统有过接触的年轻女性(涉及司法的年轻女性)遭受暴力侵害的风险更高。然而,尚无综述对预防或应对针对涉及司法的年轻女性的暴力行为的干预措施的证据进行综合分析。我们进行了一项范围综述,以确定旨在预防或应对针对涉及司法的年轻女性的暴力行为的干预措施。我们检索了Medline、《刑事司法摘要》、《科学引文索引》和谷歌学术,查找2000年1月1日至2021年3月23日期间以英文发表的同行评审文献和灰色文献。根据针对暴力行为的公共卫生方法,我们纳入了一级、二级和三级干预措施。排除重复记录后,我们的检索返回了5603条记录,其中14条符合我们的纳入标准。我们对纳入的研究进行了叙述性综合分析,所有研究均在美国进行。大多数纳入研究考察了三级干预措施(n = 10),很少有研究考察一级干预措施(n = 2)或二级干预措施(n = 2)。在乔安娜·布里格斯研究所的批判性评价工具中,符合标准的项目百分比从0%到78%不等。有一些有限的证据表明,包括认知行为疗法在内的三级干预措施减少了涉及司法的年轻女性中暴力受害对心理健康的影响。关于一级和二级干预措施的证据很少。预防针对涉及司法的年轻女性的暴力受害和再次受害的有效且基于证据的干预措施仍然是知识上的关键空白点。