Department of Surgery, Hebei Medical University, Shijiazhuang, China.
Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci. 2023 May;27(9):3799-3808. doi: 10.26355/eurrev_202305_32285.
The clinical work of ICU doctors is characterized by high intensity and medical risks, which lead to a highly stressful state for a long time and the occurrence of resignation due to long-term burnout. This study analyzes the correlation between the personal life, hospital work, social opinion, and psychological assessment of ICU physicians and their resignation intention.
This study is a multicenter questionnaire on the factors influencing resignation intention among ICU physicians. The study was completed through Critical Care E Institute (CCEI) and China Calm Therapy Research Group Academic Organization (CNCSG) by contacting critical care physicians in 3-A hospitals in 34 provinces in China. The questionnaire was in electronic format, and the results were filled in using the WeChat scan code. The survey included 22 indicators which included basic information about physicians (including gender, marriage, children, and income, etc.), hospital work (weekly working hours, on night duty, hospital environment, the evaluation of hospital's emphasis on medical staff, etc.), and SCL-90 psychological assessment.
A total of 1,749 ICU physicians completed the questionnaire. The results showed that 1,208 physicians (69.1%) intended to resign. There were statistical differences between the group's resignation intention and without resignation intention on 13 indicators. These indicators include professional title, night shift every few days, hospital hours/week, income satisfaction, work environment satisfaction, career prospect, and SCL-90 score, etc. (all p<0.05, respectively). The remaining nine indicators were not statistically different between the two groups (all p>0.05, respectively). Logistics analysis showed that working years, hospital hours (h/week), income satisfaction, work environment satisfaction, pride in hospital work, career prospects, and total SCL-90 score were all independent influences on physicians' choice of resignation intention (all p<0.05, respectively). The ROC curves' results showed that all seven indicators' predictive diagnostic value was low, with AUC areas ranging from 0.567 to 0.660. However, the combined diagnostic model of seven indicators has moderate diagnostic value. The AUC area of the model was 0.740 (95% CI: 0.718-0.760), with a sensitivity of 75.99% and specificity of 60.07%.
Physicians' income, working years, work environment satisfaction, career prospects, and psychological well-being can influence the choice of physicians' resignation intention in Chinese intensive care units. Government administration and hospitals can develop appropriate policies to enhance doctors working in hospital, thus reducing physicians' resignation choices.
ICU 医生的临床工作具有高强度和医疗风险的特点,这导致他们长期处于高度紧张状态,并且由于长期倦怠而辞职。本研究分析了 ICU 医生的个人生活、医院工作、社会意见和心理评估与辞职意愿之间的相关性。
这是一项关于影响 ICU 医生辞职意愿因素的多中心问卷调查研究。该研究由Critical Care E Institute(CCEI)和中国冷静疗法研究组学术组织(CNCSG)通过联系中国 34 个省的 3A 医院的重症监护医生完成。问卷采用电子格式,使用微信扫码填写结果。调查包括 22 个指标,包括医生的基本信息(包括性别、婚姻、子女和收入等)、医院工作(每周工作时间、上夜班、医院环境、医院对医务人员重视程度的评价等)和 SCL-90 心理评估。
共有 1749 名 ICU 医生完成了问卷。结果显示,1208 名医生(69.1%)有辞职意向。有辞职意向组和无辞职意向组在 13 个指标上存在统计学差异。这些指标包括职称、每隔几天上夜班、医院每周工作时间、收入满意度、工作环境满意度、职业前景和 SCL-90 评分等(均 p<0.05)。两组在其余 9 个指标上无统计学差异(均 p>0.05)。物流分析表明,工作年限、医院工作时间(h/周)、收入满意度、工作环境满意度、对医院工作的自豪感、职业前景和总 SCL-90 评分均为医生选择辞职意愿的独立影响因素(均 p<0.05)。ROC 曲线结果显示,所有 7 个指标的预测诊断价值均较低,AUC 面积范围为 0.567 至 0.660。然而,7 个指标的联合诊断模型具有中等的诊断价值。该模型的 AUC 面积为 0.740(95%CI:0.718-0.760),灵敏度为 75.99%,特异性为 60.07%。
中国重症监护病房医生的收入、工作年限、工作环境满意度、职业前景和心理健康状况会影响医生辞职意愿的选择。政府行政部门和医院可以制定适当的政策来增强医生在医院的工作积极性,从而减少医生的辞职选择。