Department of Sociology and Criminology, Penn State University, University Park, Pennsylvania, USA.
Aggress Behav. 2023 Jul;49(4):431-440. doi: 10.1002/ab.22090. Epub 2023 May 21.
In general, individuals with low levels of coercive power are at greater risk of victimization than those who are more powerful. However, in some circumstances, superior coercive power increases an individual's vulnerability. In this paper, I show how coercive power can increase vulnerability (offsetting its protective effect) by its effects on targeting and tactics. Individuals with greater coercive power can increase their risk of getting targeted because they tend to be less vigilant and more likely to behave in ways that provoke others. They generate more grievances and have more enemies because they are less compliant and more verbally aggressive and confrontational. Powerful parties are also at greater risk of being targeted by adversaries seeking to gain status. An attack on a strong adversary is more likely to enhance status than an attack on a weaker adversary since it is a greater achievement. Individuals with coercive power are also at greater risk because of the tactics used by their weaker adversaries. Weaker parties are more likely to engage in pre-emptive attack and use weapons. They are better able to attract and rely on allies because of the norm of social responsibility, that is, the tendency to protect those in need. Finally, they are more likely to attempt to kill more power adversaries in order to incapacitate them and, thereby, avoid retaliation.
一般来说,强制性权力较低的个体比权力更大的个体更容易受到伤害。然而,在某些情况下,更高的强制性权力会增加个体的脆弱性。在本文中,我将展示强制性权力如何通过其对目标和策略的影响来增加脆弱性(抵消其保护作用)。拥有更大强制性权力的个体更容易成为攻击目标,因为他们往往不太警惕,更有可能做出挑衅他人的行为。他们会产生更多的不满和更多的敌人,因为他们不那么顺从,更具攻击性和对抗性。更有权力的一方也更容易成为寻求获得地位的对手的攻击目标。攻击一个强大的对手比攻击一个较弱的对手更有可能提高地位,因为这是一项更大的成就。由于较弱的对手使用的策略,拥有强制性权力的个体也面临更大的风险。较弱的一方更有可能先发制人地发动攻击并使用武器。由于社会责任规范,即保护有需要的人的倾向,他们更有能力吸引和依赖盟友。最后,他们更有可能试图杀死更多权力较大的对手,以使他们失去能力,从而避免报复。