University of Otago, Wellington, New Zealand.
Massey University, Wellington, New Zealand.
Sci Rep. 2023 May 22;13(1):8254. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-35354-7.
This study aimed to estimate the optimal mix of frost resistant crops and land area needed to provide basic nutrition during various nuclear winter scenarios for New Zealand (NZ), a temperate island nation. It used linear programming to minimize land area required for cropping while producing enough food to achieve dietary energy and protein requirements for the whole population. The potential agricultural impacts of three nuclear winter scenarios on NZ, were sourced from the literature. The optimized combinations of frost resistant crops that were found to feed the entire population were, in descending order: wheat and carrots; sugar beet; oats; onions and carrots; cabbage and barley; canola and cabbage; linseed and parsnip; rye and lupins; swede and field beans; and cauliflower. But in terms of current production levels of these frost resistant crops in NZ, there would be a 26% shortfall for the "war without a nuclear winter" scenario and a 71% shortfall for the severe nuclear winter scenario (150 Tg of soot in the stratosphere with a 61% decline in crop yields). In conclusion, at current production levels, frost resistant food crops could not feed all NZ citizens following a nuclear war. There is a need for the NZ Government to conduct a detailed pre-war analysis on how these shortfalls are best addressed. For example, by: increased pre-war production of these crops and/or post-war scalability; growing enough frost sensitive crops (i.e., in greenhouses or the warmest parts of the country); and/or ensuring continuing production of food derived from livestock fed on frost resistant grasses.
本研究旨在为新西兰(NZ)这个温带岛国,估算在各种核冬天情景下提供基本营养所需的抗寒作物和土地的最佳组合。它使用线性规划来最小化作物所需的土地面积,同时生产足够的食物,以满足全体人口的膳食能量和蛋白质需求。三种核冬天情景对 NZ 的潜在农业影响,源自文献。研究发现,能够养活全体人口的抗寒作物的优化组合,按降序排列分别是:小麦和胡萝卜;糖用甜菜;燕麦;洋葱和胡萝卜;白菜和大麦;油菜和白菜;亚麻籽和欧洲防风草;黑麦和羽扇豆;芜菁和田菁;花椰菜。但就目前 NZ 这些抗寒作物的生产水平而言,在“没有核冬天的战争”情景下,会有 26%的短缺,而在严重核冬天情景下(平流层中有 150 万吨烟尘,作物产量下降 61%),会有 71%的短缺。总之,在目前的生产水平下,抗寒粮食作物无法在核战争后养活所有 NZ 公民。新西兰政府有必要对战前如何最好地解决这些短缺问题进行详细分析。例如,通过:增加这些作物的战前生产和/或战后可扩展性;种植足够的抗寒作物(即在温室或该国最温暖的地区种植);并/或确保继续生产以抗寒草为食的牲畜所衍生的食物。