Adapt Research Ltd, Reefton, New Zealand.
Rongo, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Risk Anal. 2024 Oct;44(10):2360-2376. doi: 10.1111/risa.14297. Epub 2024 Mar 16.
A major global catastrophe would likely disrupt trade in liquid fuels. Countries dependent on imported oil products might struggle to sustain industrial agriculture. Island nations importing 100% of refined fuels are particularly vulnerable. Our case study aimed to estimate the agricultural land area and biofuel volumes needed to feed the population of New Zealand in the absence of trade. Results showed that stored diesel would quickly be exhausted with ordinary use (weeks) and even with strict rationing (months). To preserve fuel, we found that farming wheat (requiring as little as 5.4 million liters [L] of diesel per annum) was more fuel-efficient than potatoes (12.3) or dairy (38.7) to feed the national population under a climate-as-usual scenario. In a nuclear winter scenario, with reduced agricultural yields, proportionately greater diesel is needed. The wheat would require 24% of current grain-cropped land, and the canola crop used as feedstock for the required biofuel would occupy a further 1%-7%. Investment in canola biodiesel or renewable diesel refineries could ensure supply for the bare minimum agricultural liquid fuel needs. Were subsequent analysis to favor this option as part of a fuels resilience response and as a tradeoff for routine food use, expansion in refining and canola cropping before a catastrophe could be encouraged through market mechanisms, direct government investment, or a combination of these. Logistics of biofuel refining scale-up, post-catastrophe, should also be analyzed. Further, biodiesel produced in normal times would help the nation meet its emissions reduction targets. Other countries should conduct similar analyses.
一场重大的全球灾难很可能会扰乱液体燃料的贸易。依赖进口石油产品的国家可能难以维持工业农业。进口 100%精炼燃料的岛国尤其脆弱。我们的案例研究旨在估算在没有贸易的情况下养活新西兰人口所需的农业土地面积和生物燃料数量。结果表明,普通使用(数周)甚至严格配给(数月),储存的柴油很快就会耗尽。为了节省燃料,我们发现,在照常情景下,种植小麦(每年只需 540 万升柴油)比种植土豆(12.3)或奶牛养殖(38.7)更能有效地为全国人口提供食物。在核冬天情景下,由于农业产量下降,需要相应增加更多的柴油。小麦将需要当前谷物种植面积的 24%,而用作所需生物燃料原料的油菜作物将进一步占用 1%-7%的土地。投资于油菜生物柴油或可再生柴油精炼厂可以确保为基本的农业液体燃料需求提供供应。如果随后的分析将这一选择作为燃料弹性应对的一部分,并作为常规食品用途的权衡,那么在灾难发生之前,可以通过市场机制、直接政府投资或两者结合的方式,鼓励扩大精炼和油菜种植规模。还应分析生物燃料精炼规模扩大的后勤问题。此外,正常时期生产的生物柴油将有助于国家实现减排目标。其他国家也应该进行类似的分析。