Carollo Alessandro, Bizzego Andrea, Gabrieli Giulio, Wong Keri Ka-Yee, Raine Adrian, Esposito Gianluca
Department of Psychology and Cognitive Science, University of Trento, Rovereto, Italy.
School of Social Sciences, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore, Singapore.
UCL Open Environ. 2022 Nov 3;4:e051. doi: 10.14324/111.444/ucloe.000051. eCollection 2022.
The global Covid-19 pandemic has forced countries to impose strict lockdown restrictions and mandatory stay-at-home orders with varying impacts on individual's health. Combining a data-driven machine learning paradigm and a statistical approach, our previous paper documented a U-shaped pattern in levels of self-perceived loneliness in both the UK and Greek populations during the first lockdown (17 April to 17 July 2020). The current paper aimed to test the robustness of these results by focusing on data from the first and second lockdown waves in the UK. We tested a) the impact of the chosen model on the identification of the most time-sensitive variable in the period spent in lockdown. Two new machine learning models - namely, support vector regressor (SVR) and multiple linear regressor (MLR) were adopted to identify the most time-sensitive variable in the UK dataset from Wave 1 (n = 435). In the second part of the study, we tested b) whether the pattern of self-perceived loneliness found in the first UK national lockdown was generalisable to the second wave of the UK lockdown (17 October 2020 to 31 January 2021). To do so, data from Wave 2 of the UK lockdown (n = 263) was used to conduct a graphical inspection of the week-by-week distribution of self-perceived loneliness scores. In both SVR and MLR models, depressive symptoms resulted to be the most time-sensitive variable during the lockdown period. Statistical analysis of depressive symptoms by week of lockdown resulted in a U-shaped pattern between weeks 3 and 7 of Wave 1 of the UK national lockdown. Furthermore, although the sample size by week in Wave 2 was too small to have a meaningful statistical insight, a graphical U-shaped distribution between weeks 3 and 9 of lockdown was observed. Consistent with past studies, these preliminary results suggest that self-perceived loneliness and depressive symptoms may be two of the most relevant symptoms to address when imposing lockdown restrictions.
全球新冠疫情迫使各国实施严格的封锁限制措施和强制居家令,这对个人健康产生了不同程度的影响。结合数据驱动的机器学习范式和统计方法,我们之前的论文记录了英国和希腊人群在首次封锁期间(2020年4月17日至7月17日)自我感知孤独感水平呈U形模式。本文旨在通过关注英国第一波和第二波封锁的数据来检验这些结果的稳健性。我们测试了:a)所选模型对确定封锁期间最具时间敏感性变量的影响。采用了两种新的机器学习模型——支持向量回归器(SVR)和多元线性回归器(MLR),以确定英国第一波数据集(n = 435)中最具时间敏感性的变量。在研究的第二部分,我们测试了:b)在英国首次全国封锁中发现的自我感知孤独感模式是否适用于英国第二波封锁(2020年10月17日至2021年1月31日)。为此,使用英国第二波封锁的数据(n = 263)对自我感知孤独感得分的逐周分布进行图形检查。在SVR和MLR模型中,抑郁症状在封锁期间都是最具时间敏感性的变量。对英国全国封锁第一波第3周和第7周之间按周对抑郁症状进行统计分析,结果呈U形模式。此外,尽管第二波按周的样本量太小,无法获得有意义的统计见解,但在封锁的第3周和第9周之间观察到了图形上的U形分布。与过去的研究一致,这些初步结果表明,自我感知孤独感和抑郁症状可能是实施封锁限制时需要解决的两个最相关症状。