Wada H
Nihon Seikeigeka Gakkai Zasshi. 1986 Mar;60(3):295-306.
Seventy patients classified as Tossy's Grade III acromioclavicular dislocation were studied clinically and radiographically, and treated conservatively. Twenty acromioclavicular joints from 11 cadavers were dissected for a detailed anatomical evaluation of acromioclavicular joints. Anatomical findings showed that the conoid ligament played an important role for the fixation of the clavicular end to the acromion. Patients with dislocation classified as Tossy's Grade III were divided into two subtypes, A and B, according to the distance between the clavicle and acromion on the radiograph. Arthorography was performed on 22 patients. The arthograms were classified into three types, I, II and III, depending on the leak spread and flow of the contrast medium around the acromioclavicular joints. Types I and II arthorograms were seen in all cases classified as Type A on X-rays, most of the Type III arthorograms were seen in cases classified as Type B. Favorable results were obtained in eighty-six per cent of Type A cases. Fair to poor results, however, were achieved in 60% of type B cases. From the result of this study, the author concludes that Tossy's Grade III, complete dislocation, should be classified into two subtypes and surgical treatment should be considered for Type B or complete dislocation.
对70例被归类为TossyⅢ型肩锁关节脱位的患者进行了临床和影像学研究,并采用保守治疗。对11具尸体的20个肩锁关节进行了解剖,以对肩锁关节进行详细的解剖学评估。解剖学发现表明,锥形韧带在锁骨端与肩峰的固定中起重要作用。根据X线片上锁骨与肩峰之间的距离,将TossyⅢ型脱位患者分为A、B两个亚型。对22例患者进行了关节造影。根据造影剂在肩锁关节周围的渗漏扩散和流动情况,关节造影片分为Ⅰ、Ⅱ、Ⅲ三种类型。X线片上所有A类病例均可见Ⅰ型和Ⅱ型关节造影片,大多数Ⅲ型关节造影片见于B类病例。A类病例86%取得了良好效果。然而,B类病例60%的结果为一般至较差。根据本研究结果,作者得出结论,TossyⅢ型完全脱位应分为两个亚型,B型或完全脱位应考虑手术治疗。