Ashall Vanessa
Science and Technology Studies Unit (SATSU), Department of Sociology, Heslington East Campus, University of York, York YO10 5GD, UK.
Animals (Basel). 2023 May 17;13(10):1662. doi: 10.3390/ani13101662.
This study examines experiences of veterinary moral stress in charity veterinary practice and qualitatively evaluates the role of ethical discussion in reducing veterinary moral stress. Results are drawn from a thematic data analysis of 9 focus groups and 15 individual interviews with veterinary team members from 3 UK charity veterinary hospitals. Moral stress is described as an everyday experience by participants and is caused by uncertainty about their ability to fulfill their ethical obligations. Moral stress is shown to be cumulative and can interact with other forms of stress. Distinct practical and relational barriers to ethical action are identified and proposed as contributors to moral stress, and different team members experience different barriers within their roles. The potential impact of moral stress on team members' quality of life and mental health is highlighted. Results show that regular facilitated ethical group discussions may reduce moral stress in the hospital setting, particularly through familiarization with others' roles and ethical perspectives and through supporting one another's ethical decision-making. The article concludes that moral stress is an important and poorly understood problem in veterinary practice and that further development of regular facilitated ethical group discussion may be of considerable benefit to team members.
本研究考察了慈善兽医实践中兽医道德压力的经历,并对伦理讨论在减轻兽医道德压力中的作用进行了定性评估。研究结果来自对英国3家慈善兽医医院的兽医团队成员进行的9个焦点小组和15次个人访谈的主题数据分析。参与者将道德压力描述为一种日常经历,其产生原因是他们对履行道德义务能力的不确定性。研究表明,道德压力具有累积性,并且会与其他形式的压力相互作用。研究确定了道德行为存在明显的实践和关系障碍,并认为这些障碍是道德压力的成因,不同的团队成员在其角色中会经历不同的障碍。研究强调了道德压力对团队成员生活质量和心理健康的潜在影响。结果表明,定期组织的伦理小组讨论可能会减轻医院环境中的道德压力,特别是通过熟悉他人的角色和伦理观点,以及通过相互支持道德决策来实现。文章得出结论,道德压力是兽医实践中一个重要但却鲜为人知的问题,定期组织的伦理小组讨论的进一步发展可能会给团队成员带来相当大的益处。