Mestermann Stefan, Fasching Peter A, Beckmann Matthias W, Gerlach Jennifer, Kratz Oliver, Moll Gunther H, Kornhuber Johannes, Eichler Anna
Department of Child and Adolescent Mental Health, University Hospital Erlangen, Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg (FAU), 91054 Erlangen, Germany.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University Hospital Erlangen, Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg (FAU), 91054 Erlangen, Germany.
Children (Basel). 2023 May 12;10(5):866. doi: 10.3390/children10050866.
Pregnancy anamnesis is a crucial part of child and adolescent psychiatry diagnostics. In previous works, the reliability of retrospective maternal self-report on perinatal characteristics was heterogeneous. This prospective longitudinal study aimed to evaluate women's recall of prenatal events in a within-subject design. A sample of 241 women gave a self-report on prenatal alcohol, smoking, partnership quality, pregnancy satisfaction, and obstetric complications during the 3rd trimester (t0), childhood (t1, 6-10 y), and adolescence (t2, 12-14 y). The intra-individual agreement was examined. The t0-t1-(t2) agreement was poor to substantial; this was highest for smoking and worst for obstetric complications, followed by alcohol (Fleiss' κ = 0.719 to -0.051). There were significant t0-t1-(t2) differences for all pregnancy variables ( < 0.017), except for 3rd trimester satisfaction ( = 0.256). For alcohol (t0 25.8%, t1 17.4%, t2 41.0%) and smoking (t0 11.9%, t1 16.4%, t2 22.6%), the highest self-reported rates were found during adolescence. During childhood, fewer obstetric complications (t0 84.9%, t1 42.2%) and worse partnerships were reported (t0 M = 8.86, t1 M = 7.89). Thought to be due to social stigmata and memory effects, pregnancy self-reports cannot be precisely reproduced. Creating a respectful and trusting atmosphere is essential for mothers to give honest self-reports that are in the best interest of their children.
妊娠史是儿童和青少年精神病学诊断的关键部分。在以往的研究中,母亲对围产期特征的回顾性自我报告的可靠性参差不齐。这项前瞻性纵向研究旨在通过受试者内设计评估女性对产前事件的回忆。241名女性样本在孕晚期(t0)、童年期(t1,6 - 10岁)和青春期(t2,12 - 14岁)对产前饮酒、吸烟、伴侣关系质量、妊娠满意度和产科并发症进行了自我报告。研究了个体内的一致性。t0 - t1 -(t2)的一致性从差到中等;吸烟方面的一致性最高,产科并发症方面最差,其次是饮酒(Fleiss' κ = 0.719至 - 0.051)。除孕晚期满意度(P = 0.256)外,所有妊娠变量的t0 - t1 -(t2)差异均有统计学意义(P < 0.017)。对于饮酒(t0为25.8%,t1为17.4%,t2为41.0%)和吸烟(t0为11.9%,t1为16.4%,t2为22.6%),自我报告率在青春期最高。在童年期,报告的产科并发症较少(t0为84.9%,t1为42.2%),伴侣关系较差(t0均值 = 8.86,t1均值 = 7.89)。由于社会耻辱感和记忆效应,妊娠自我报告无法精确重现。营造尊重和信任的氛围对于母亲给出符合孩子最佳利益的诚实自我报告至关重要。