Lamoureux Daniel, Yeo Sarah, Bhambhwani Vishaal
Ophthalmology, Northern Ontario School of Medicine, Thunder Bay, CAN.
Ophthalmology, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, CAN.
Cureus. 2023 Apr 27;15(4):e38196. doi: 10.7759/cureus.38196. eCollection 2023 Apr.
Background The International Reading Speed Texts (IReST) are commonly used to measure reading speed, which may be affected in many eye conditions. They were originally tested in a younger British population. Our study evaluates IReST in a Canadian population. Methodology A Canadian cohort in Ontario was prospectively recruited with age >14 years, education >9 years, English as the primary language, and best-corrected visual acuity >20/25 distance and >N8 near in each eye. Participants with eye conditions and neurological/cognitive problems were excluded. Each participant consecutively read two IReST passages (passages 1 and 8). Reading speed in words per minute (WPM) was calculated. One-sample t-test was used to compare our cohort to published IReST standards. Results A total of 112 participants were included (35 male, 77 female). The mean age was 40 ± 17 years (14-18 years: 12; 18-35 years: 34; 35-60 years: 53; 60-75 years: 13). The mean reading speed for passage 1 was 211 ± 33 WPM compared to the published IReST standard of 236 ± 29 WPM (p < 0.0001). The mean reading speed for passage 8 was 218 ± 34 WPM compared to the IReST standard of 237 ± 24 WPM (p < 0.0001). Thus, our cohort read slower for both passages compared to IReST standards. The mean reading speed for passages 1 and 8 was the highest for the 14-18-year (231 and 239, respectively) and the lowest for the 60-75-year group (195 and 192, respectively). Conclusions Normal older populations have slower reading compared to younger populations. The slower reading in our cohort may also be because the passages were in British rather than in Canadian English. It is important that the IReST is evaluated in different populations to ensure reliable comparison standards for future research.
背景 国际阅读速度文本(IReST)常用于测量阅读速度,其在多种眼部疾病中可能会受到影响。IReST最初是在较年轻的英国人群中进行测试的。我们的研究对加拿大人群中的IReST进行评估。方法 前瞻性招募安大略省年龄大于14岁、受教育年限大于9年、以英语为主要语言且每只眼睛最佳矫正视力在远距离大于20/25、近距离大于N8的加拿大队列。排除患有眼部疾病和神经/认知问题的参与者。每位参与者连续阅读两篇IReST文章(文章1和文章8)。计算每分钟单词阅读速度(WPM)。使用单样本t检验将我们的队列与已发表的IReST标准进行比较。结果 共纳入112名参与者(35名男性,77名女性)。平均年龄为40±17岁(14 - 18岁:12人;18 - 35岁:34人;35 - 60岁:53人;60 - 75岁:13人)。文章1的平均阅读速度为211±33WPM,而已发表的IReST标准为236±29WPM(p < 0.0001)。文章8的平均阅读速度为218±34WPM,而IReST标准为237±24WPM(p < 0.0001)。因此,与IReST标准相比,我们的队列阅读这两篇文章的速度都较慢。文章1和文章8的平均阅读速度在14 - 18岁组最高(分别为231和239),在60 - 75岁组最低(分别为195和192)。结论 与年轻人群相比,正常老年人群的阅读速度较慢。我们队列中阅读速度较慢也可能是因为文章使用的是英式英语而非加拿大英语。对不同人群评估IReST很重要,以确保未来研究有可靠的比较标准。