Curran Shannon N, Schaefer Audra F
Department of Neurobiology and Anatomical Sciences, University of Mississippi Medical Center, Jackson, MS 39216, USA.
Med Sci Educ. 2023 Feb 18;33(2):385-393. doi: 10.1007/s40670-023-01745-8. eCollection 2023 Apr.
There is an ongoing debate in anatomy education regarding the use of prosection versus student dissection in anatomy lab instruction. While there are plenty of studies comparing dissection and prosection, there are very few studies on how prosections are prepared and how they are used in anatomy instruction. Furthermore, there is no consistent definition of prosection used in the literature. This study used an anonymous questionnaire distributed to anatomy educators internationally and asked for educator views on defining, preparing, and using prosections in various course settings. One-hundred twenty-five completed responses representing fifteen countries and sixty-seven institutions underwent a thematic analysis to describe major themes in participant responses. From responses, a definition of prosection was developed, and the major perceived strengths and weaknesses of prosection use were described. Furthermore, quantitative data regarding the prevalence of prosection use as either a supplemental or primary resource and details pertaining to the perceived expertise of prosectors was collected. This study demonstrates the extensive reach of prosections in anatomy education and sets a foundation from which future studies on unique prosection preparation and use can stem from.
在解剖学教育领域,关于在解剖实验室教学中使用预先解剖标本与学生进行实际解剖存在着持续的争论。虽然有大量研究比较了解剖和预先解剖标本,但关于预先解剖标本是如何制备的以及它们在解剖学教学中是如何使用的研究却很少。此外,文献中对预先解剖标本没有一致的定义。本研究通过向国际解剖学教育工作者发放一份匿名调查问卷,询问他们在各种课程设置中对预先解剖标本的定义、制备和使用的看法。代表15个国家和67个机构的125份完整回复接受了主题分析,以描述参与者回复中的主要主题。从回复中,得出了预先解剖标本的定义,并描述了使用预先解剖标本的主要感知优势和劣势。此外,还收集了关于预先解剖标本作为补充或主要资源使用的普遍性的定量数据,以及与预先解剖标本制备者感知专业知识相关的细节。本研究展示了预先解剖标本在解剖学教育中的广泛应用,并为未来关于独特的预先解剖标本制备和使用的研究奠定了基础。