Baig Khalid Saifullah, Hayat Muhammad Khizar, Khan Mohammad Ahmed Arsalan, Humayun Umer, Ahmad Zunnoor, Khan Muhammad Afaq
Internal Medicine, Hayatabad Medical Complex, Peshawar, PAK.
Pediatric Surgery, Children's Health Ireland, Dublin, IRL.
Cureus. 2023 May 3;15(5):e38487. doi: 10.7759/cureus.38487. eCollection 2023 May.
Objectives To determine the level of empathy in medical students and to determine the difference in empathy levels between the two genders in a single center. Materials & methods This qualitative study was conducted at a medical college in Peshawar from March 2021 to July 2021. Institutional ethical committee approval was taken (RMI/RMI-REC/Approval/83) before commencing the study. All students admitted into the medical college in the current academic year 2020 to 2021 were included in the study. Any students that did not fill out the questionnaire completely were excluded. The Toronto Empathy Questionnaire (TEQ) was used in this study. The questionnaire was uploaded on google forms for data collection. All the resulting scores were entered into IBM SPSS version 23.0. The mean TEQ score was calculated. Box and whisker plots were made for respective years. An Independent sample t-test was used to determine the association between mean TEQ scores and gender. Results Of 367 students, 347 (94.6%) participated in this study, with a slight female predominance (53%). The mean age of the students was 21.44 (SD = 1.751) years. The participation rate was 70% from each class. Most participants across the years have an above-average empathy score (49.9%). Among the participants, the year I (67.6%) showed most participants with high empathy. Year IV (40.6%) has the highest proportion of below-average empathy scores. The mean empathy score of female students was 49.08 (S.D = 7.588), while the empathy score for male students was 44.59 (S.D = 7.58). Conclusion Empathy levels decline as medical education is progressed through the years. Females show a greater sense of empathy than their male counterparts. A slight increase in empathy levels is seen in the final year of medical school after a decline over the initial years.
确定医学生的共情水平,并确定单一中心内两性之间共情水平的差异。
本定性研究于2021年3月至2021年7月在白沙瓦的一所医学院进行。在研究开始前获得了机构伦理委员会的批准(RMI/RMI-REC/批准/83)。2020至2021学年进入该医学院的所有学生均纳入研究。任何未完整填写问卷的学生均被排除。本研究使用了多伦多共情问卷(TEQ)。问卷上传至谷歌表单进行数据收集。所有所得分数均录入IBM SPSS 23.0版本。计算TEQ平均分数。为各年份绘制箱线图。使用独立样本t检验确定TEQ平均分数与性别之间的关联。
在367名学生中,347名(94.6%)参与了本研究,女性略占优势(53%)。学生的平均年龄为21.44岁(标准差=1.751)。每个班级的参与率为70%。多年来,大多数参与者的共情分数高于平均水平(49.9%)。在参与者中,一年级(67.6%)表现出高共情的参与者最多。四年级(40.6%)的共情分数低于平均水平的比例最高。女学生的平均共情分数为49.08(标准差=7.588),而男学生的共情分数为44.59(标准差=7.58)。
随着医学教育逐年推进,共情水平会下降。女性比男性表现出更强的共情意识。在医学院最初几年下降后,最后一年共情水平略有上升。