Wells K B, Lewis C E, Leake B, Schleiter M K, Brook R H
Am J Public Health. 1986 Aug;76(8):1009-13. doi: 10.2105/ajph.76.8.1009.
We compared the practices of subspecialists and general internists in counseling about smoking and exercise, using data from a study of recent graduates of United States training programs in internal medicine. Information on the characteristics of physicians and their clinical practices was obtained from self-report questionnaires. The internists most likely to counsel smokers regardless of the presence or absence of diseases associated with smoking are cardiologists, pulmonary specialists, nephrologists, and generalists trained in a primary care residency funded by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation or Health Resources Administration. Most internists practice tertiary prevention by counseling a high percentage of smokers with heart or lung disease. Rheumatologists counsel a higher percentage of all patients with poor exercise habits but a lower percentage of such patients with heart disease than do other internists. The differences in counseling related to training are not explained by different levels of involvement as a primary care physician. Rather, these differences appear to reflect training and subspecialty-specific priorities for counseling.
我们利用一项针对美国内科培训项目近期毕业生的研究数据,比较了亚专科医生和普通内科医生在吸烟与运动咨询方面的做法。医生的特征及其临床实践信息通过自我报告问卷获得。无论是否存在与吸烟相关的疾病,最有可能为吸烟者提供咨询的内科医生是心脏病专家、肺科专家、肾病专家,以及在由罗伯特·伍德·约翰逊基金会或卫生资源管理局资助的初级保健住院医师培训项目中接受培训的全科医生。大多数内科医生通过为高比例的患有心脏病或肺病的吸烟者提供咨询来实施三级预防。与其他内科医生相比,风湿病学家为所有运动习惯不良患者提供咨询的比例更高,但为患有心脏病的此类患者提供咨询的比例更低。与培训相关的咨询差异并不能通过作为初级保健医生的不同参与程度来解释。相反,这些差异似乎反映了培训和亚专科特定的咨询重点。