Department of Medical Education, Bioethics and Humanity, Bandung Islamic University, Bandung, Indonesia.
Department of Biochemistry and Nutrition, Bandung Islamic University, Bandung, Indonesia.
Korean J Med Educ. 2023 Jun;35(2):143-152. doi: 10.3946/kjme.2023.255. Epub 2023 Jun 1.
A doctor's professional behavior and clinical competency reflect a range of personal and interpersonal qualities, attributes, commitments, and values. This study aimed to identify the most influential factor of medical competence regarding patient management ability.
We used an analytic observational design with a cross-sectional approach, and gathered the perceptions of medical school graduates of Bandung Islamic University via an online questionnaire scored on a Likert scale. Two hundred and six medical graduates who graduated at least 3 years prior to survey were included in the study. The factors evaluated included humanism, cognitive competence, clinical skill competence, professional behavior, patient management ability, and interpersonal skill. IBM AMOS ver. 26.0 (IBM Corp., Armonk, USA) was used for structural equation modelling of the six variables latent and 35 indicator variables.
We found that graduates have highly positive perceptions of the humanism (95.67%). Followed by interpersonal skills (91.26%), patient management (89.53%), professional behavior (88.47%), and cognitive competence (87.12%). They rated clinical skill competence the lowest (81.7%). Regarding factors that contribute to patient management ability, the aspects of humanism, interpersonal skill, and professional behavior were found to significantly affect patient management ability (p-value=0.035, 0.00, and 0.00, respectively) with a critical rate of 2.11, 4.31, and 4.26 consecutively.
Humanism and interpersonal skill are two important factors that medical graduates assessed very positively. According to surveyed medical graduates, their expectations of the institution were met regarding humanism. However, there is a need to strengthen medical students' clinical skills and improve their cognitive abilities through educational programs.
医生的专业行为和临床能力反映了一系列个人和人际素质、属性、承诺和价值观。本研究旨在确定影响患者管理能力的医学能力的最主要因素。
我们采用分析性观察设计,采用横断面方法,通过在线问卷收集万隆伊斯兰大学医学院毕业生的意见,该问卷采用李克特量表评分。研究纳入了至少在调查前 3 年毕业的 206 名医学毕业生。评估的因素包括人文主义、认知能力、临床技能能力、专业行为、患者管理能力和人际交往能力。使用 IBM AMOS ver. 26.0(IBM 公司,美国阿蒙克)对 6 个潜在变量和 35 个指标变量进行结构方程模型分析。
我们发现毕业生对人文主义的评价非常高(95.67%)。其次是人际交往能力(91.26%)、患者管理能力(89.53%)、专业行为(88.47%)和认知能力(87.12%)。他们对临床技能能力的评价最低(81.7%)。关于影响患者管理能力的因素,人文主义、人际交往能力和专业行为被发现对患者管理能力有显著影响(p 值分别为 0.035、0.00 和 0.00),临界率分别为 2.11、4.31 和 4.26。
人文主义和人际交往能力是医学毕业生评价非常高的两个重要因素。根据调查的医学毕业生的意见,他们对机构的人文主义方面的期望得到了满足。然而,需要通过教育项目加强医学生的临床技能和提高他们的认知能力。