Amin Muhammad, Ullah Khalil, Asif Muhammad, Shah Habib, Mehmood Arshad, Khan Muhammad Attique
Department of Electronics, University of Peshawar, Peshawar 25120, Pakistan.
Department of Computer Science, Iqra National University, Peshawar 25000, Pakistan.
Diagnostics (Basel). 2023 May 29;13(11):1897. doi: 10.3390/diagnostics13111897.
Mental stress is known as a prime factor in road crashes. The devastation of these crashes often results in damage to humans, vehicles, and infrastructure. Likewise, persistent mental stress could lead to the development of mental, cardiovascular, and abdominal disorders. Preceding research in this domain mostly focuses on feature engineering and conventional machine learning approaches. These approaches recognize different levels of stress based on handcrafted features extracted from various modalities including physiological, physical, and contextual data. Acquiring good quality features from these modalities using feature engineering is often a difficult job. Recent developments in the form of deep learning (DL) algorithms have relieved feature engineering by automatically extracting and learning resilient features. This paper proposes different CNN and CNN-LSTSM-based fusion models using physiological signals (SRAD dataset) and multimodal data (AffectiveROAD dataset) for the driver's two and three stress levels. The fuzzy EDAS (evaluation based on distance from average solution) approach is used to evaluate the performance of the proposed models based on different classification metrics (accuracy, recall, precision, F-score, and specificity). Fuzzy EDAS performance estimation shows that the proposed CNN and hybrid CNN-LSTM models achieved the first ranks based on the fusion of BH, E4-Left (E4-L), and E4-Right (E4-R). Results showed the significance of multimodal data for designing an accurate and trustworthy stress recognition diagnosing model for real-world driving conditions. The proposed model can also be used for the diagnosis of the stress level of a subject during other daily life activities.
精神压力被认为是道路交通事故的一个主要因素。这些事故的破坏往往会导致人员、车辆和基础设施的损坏。同样,持续的精神压力可能会导致精神、心血管和腹部疾病的发展。该领域之前的研究大多集中在特征工程和传统机器学习方法上。这些方法基于从包括生理、身体和上下文数据等各种模态中提取的手工特征来识别不同程度的压力。使用特征工程从这些模态中获取高质量的特征通常是一项艰巨的任务。深度学习(DL)算法形式的最新进展通过自动提取和学习弹性特征减轻了特征工程的负担。本文针对驾驶员的两种和三种压力水平,提出了使用生理信号(SRAD数据集)和多模态数据(AffectiveROAD数据集)的不同基于卷积神经网络(CNN)和CNN-长短期记忆网络(LSTSM)的融合模型。基于模糊EDAS(基于与平均解的距离的评估)方法,根据不同的分类指标(准确率、召回率、精确率、F分数和特异性)来评估所提出模型的性能。模糊EDAS性能估计表明,所提出的CNN和混合CNN-LSTM模型基于脑电(BH)、左E4传感器(E4-L)和右E4传感器(E4-R)的融合获得了第一名。结果表明了多模态数据对于设计适用于现实驾驶条件的准确且可靠的压力识别诊断模型的重要性。所提出的模型还可用于诊断受试者在其他日常生活活动中的压力水平。