Heinbecker P
Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law. 1986;14(2):185-91.
The author examined the records of the seven defendants found not guilty by reason of insanity (NGI) under Utah's mens rea insanity law during the first two years of its operation. In all of the cases the attorneys, judges, and experts seemed unaware of the new law or confused about its meaning. Examination revealed that the findings of insanity were negotiated with either ignorance of or indifference to the mens rea law. Under the mens rea NGI law, the rate of insanity findings for Utah increased.
作者审查了犹他州“犯罪意图精神错乱”法律实施头两年里因精神错乱而被判无罪(NGI)的七名被告的记录。在所有这些案件中,律师、法官和专家似乎都不知道这项新法律,或者对其含义感到困惑。审查发现,精神错乱的判定是在对犯罪意图法律无知或漠不关心的情况下进行协商的。根据“犯罪意图精神错乱”法律,犹他州精神错乱判定的比例有所上升。